Buschau v. Rogers Communications Incorporated, 2012 FCA 197 (2012)

Parts:Buschau v. Rogers Communications Incorporated
Reporting Judge:DAWSON J.A.
Docket Number:A-290-11
 
FREE EXCERPT

Federal Court of Appeal - Buschau v. Rogers Communications Incorporated [Anonymoused]

Source: http://decisions.fca-caf.gc.ca/en/2012/2012fca197/2012fca197.html

Date: 20120628

Docket: A-290-11

Citation: 2012 FCA 197

CORAM: DAWSON J.A.

GAUTHIER J.A.

STRATAS J.A.

BETWEEN:

SANDRA BUSCHAU, SHARON M. PARENT, ALBERT POY, DAVID ALLEN,

EILEEN ANDERSON, CHRISTINE ASH, FREDERICK SCOTT ATKINSON,

JASPAL BADYAL, MARY BALFRY, CAROLYN LOUISE BARRY, RAJ

BHAMBER, EVELYN BISHOP, DEBORAH LOUISE BISSONNETTE, GEORGE BOSHKO, COLLEEN BURKE, BRIAN CARROLL, LYNN CASSIDY, FLORENCE K. COLBECK, PETER COLISTRO, ERNEST A. COTTLE, KEN DANN, DONNA DE FREITAS, TERRY DEWELL, KATRIN DOLEMEYER, ELIZABETH ENGEL,

KAREN ENGLESON, GEORGE FIERHELLER, JOAN FISHER, GWEN FORD, DON

R. FRASER, MABEL GARWOOD, CHERYL GERVAIS, ROSE GIBB, ROGER

GILODO, MURRAY GJERNES, DAPHNE GOODE, KAREN L. GOULD, PETER

JAMES HADIKIN, MARIAN HEIBLOEM-REEVES, THOMAS HOBLEY, JOHN

IANNANTUONI, VINCENT A. IANNANTUONI, RON INGLIS, MEHROON

JANMOHAMED, MICHAEL J. JERVIS, MARLYN KELLNER, KAREN KILBA,

DOUGLAS JAMES KILGOUR, YOSHINORI KOGA, MARTIN KOSULJANDIC,

URSULA M. KREIGER, WING LEE, ROBERT LESLIE, THOMAS A.

LEWTHWAITE, HOLLY LI, DAVID LIDDELL, RITA LIM, BETTY C. LLOYD, ROB

LOWRIE, CHE-CHUNG MA, JENNIFER MACDONALD, ROBERT JOHN

MACLEOD, SHERRY M. MADDEN, TOM MAKORTOFF, FATIMA MANJI, EDWARD

B. MASON, GLENN A. MCFARLANE, ONAGH METCALFE, DOROTHY

MITCHELL, SHIRLEY C.T. MUI, WILLIAM NEAL, KATHERINE SHEILA NIMMO,

GLORIA PAIEMENT, LYNDA PASACRETA, BARBARA PEAKE, VERA PICCINI, INEZ PINKERTON, DAVE PODWORNY, DOUG PONTIFEX, VICTORIA PROCHASKA, FRANK RADELJA, GALE RAUK, RUTH ROBERTS, ANN LOUISE RODGERS, CIFFORD JAMES ROE, PAMELA MAMON ROE, DELORES ROSE, SABRINA ROZA-PEREIRA, SANDRA RYBCHINSKY, KENNETH T. SALMOND, MARIE SCHNEIDER, ALEXANDER C. SCOTT, INDERJEET SHARMA, HUGH DONALD SHIEL, MICHAEL SHIRLEY, GEORGE ALLEN SHORT, GLENDA SIMONCIONI, NORM SMALLWOOD, GILLES A. ST. DENNIS, GERI STEPHEN, GRACE ISOBEL STONE, MARI TSANG, CARMEN TUVERA, SHEERA WAISMAN, MARGARET WATSON, GERTRUDE WESTLAKE, ROBERT E. WHITE, PATRICIA JANE WHITEHEAD, AILEEN WILSON, ELAINE WIRTZ, JOE WUYCHUK, ZLATKA YOUNG

Appellants and

ROGERS COMMUNICATIONS INCORPORATED

Respondent

Heard at Vancouver, British Columbia , on June 20, 2012.

Judgment delivered at Ottawa, Ontario , on June 28, 2012.

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT BY: DAWSON J.A.

CONCURRED IN BY: GAUTHIER J.A.

STRATAS J.A.

Date: 20120628

Docket: A-290-11

Citation: 2012 FCA 197

CORAM: DAWSON J.A.

GAUTHIER J.A.

STRATAS J.A.

BETWEEN:

SANDRA BUSCHAU, SHARON M. PARENT, ALBERT POY, DAVID ALLEN,

EILEEN ANDERSON, CHRISTINE ASH, FREDERICK SCOTT ATKINSON,

JASPAL BADYAL, MARY BALFRY, CAROLYN LOUISE BARRY, RAJ

BHAMBER, EVELYN BISHOP, DEBORAH LOUISE BISSONNETTE, GEORGE BOSHKO, COLLEEN BURKE, BRIAN CARROLL, LYNN CASSIDY, FLORENCE K. COLBECK, PETER COLISTRO, ERNEST A. COTTLE, KEN DANN, DONNA DE FREITAS, TERRY DEWELL, KATRIN DOLEMEYER, ELIZABETH ENGEL,

KAREN ENGLESON, GEORGE FIERHELLER, JOAN FISHER, GWEN FORD, DON

R. FRASER, MABEL GARWOOD, CHERYL GERVAIS, ROSE GIBB, ROGER

GILODO, MURRAY GJERNES, DAPHNE GOODE, KAREN L. GOULD, PETER

JAMES HADIKIN, MARIAN HEIBLOEM-REEVES, THOMAS HOBLEY, JOHN

IANNANTUONI, VINCENT A. IANNANTUONI, RON INGLIS, MEHROON

JANMOHAMED, MICHAEL J. JERVIS, MARLYN KELLNER, KAREN KILBA,

DOUGLAS JAMES KILGOUR, YOSHINORI KOGA, MARTIN KOSULJANDIC,

URSULA M. KREIGER, WING LEE, ROBERT LESLIE, THOMAS A.

LEWTHWAITE, HOLLY LI, DAVID LIDDELL, RITA LIM, BETTY C. LLOYD, ROB

LOWRIE, CHE-CHUNG MA, JENNIFER MACDONALD, ROBERT JOHN

MACLEOD, SHERRY M. MADDEN, TOM MAKORTOFF, FATIMA MANJI, EDWARD

B. MASON, GLENN A. MCFARLANE, ONAGH METCALFE, DOROTHY

MITCHELL, SHIRLEY C.T. MUI, WILLIAM NEAL, KATHERINE SHEILA NIMMO,

GLORIA PAIEMENT, LYNDA PASACRETA, BARBARA PEAKE, VERA PICCINI, INEZ PINKERTON, DAVE PODWORNY, DOUG PONTIFEX, VICTORIA PROCHASKA, FRANK RADELJA, GALE RAUK, RUTH ROBERTS, ANN LOUISE RODGERS, CIFFORD JAMES ROE, PAMELA MAMON ROE, DELORES ROSE, SABRINA ROZA-PEREIRA, SANDRA RYBCHINSKY, KENNETH T. SALMOND, MARIE SCHNEIDER, ALEXANDER C. SCOTT, INDERJEET SHARMA, HUGH DONALD SHIEL, MICHAEL SHIRLEY, GEORGE ALLEN SHORT, GLENDA SIMONCIONI, NORM SMALLWOOD, GILLES A. ST. DENNIS, GERI STEPHEN, GRACE ISOBEL STONE, MARI TSANG, CARMEN TUVERA, SHEERA WAISMAN, MARGARET WATSON, GERTRUDE WESTLAKE, ROBERT E. WHITE, PATRICIA JANE WHITEHEAD, AILEEN WILSON, ELAINE WIRTZ, JOE WUYCHUK, ZLATKA YOUNG

Appellants and

ROGERS COMMUNICATIONS INCORPORATED

Respondent

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

DAWSON J.A.

[1] This is an appeal from a decision of the Federal Court. In thorough and thoughtful reasons (2011 FC 911, 337 D.L.R. (4 th ) 467) the Federal Court dismissed an application for judicial review of a decision, made on November 4, 2010, by the Office of the Superintendent of Financial Institutions Canada (Superintendent) not to give fresh consideration to eight issues raised by the appellants.

Factual...

To continue reading

REQUEST YOUR FREE TRIAL