Canadian Imperial Bank of Commerce v. Torre, 2010 FC 105
| Jurisdiction | Federal Jurisdiction (Canada) |
| Court | Federal Court |
| Judge | Martineau, J. |
| Citation | 2010 FC 105,(2010), 362 F.T.R. 232 (FC) |
| Date | 12 January 2010 |
| Subject Matter | LABOUR LAW |
CIBC v. Torre (2010), 362 F.T.R. 232 (FC)
MLB headnote and full text
[French language version follows English language version]
[La version française vient à la suite de la version anglaise]
.........................
Temp. Cite: [2010] F.T.R. TBEd. JA.053
Banque Canadienne Impériale de Commerce (demanderesse) v. Nellie Torre (défenderesse)
(T-622-09; 2010 CF 105; 2010 FC 105)
Indexed As: Canadian Imperial Bank of Commerce v. Torre
Federal Court
Martineau, J.
January 29, 2010.
Summary:
Torre was dismissed by her employer, the Canadian Imperial Bank of Commerce, for having breached the Bank's confidentiality rules. She held a position as manager and supervised five employees. Torre filed a complaint for unjust dismissal under s. 240 of the Canada Labour Code. The Bank submitted that Torre was a "manager" and therefore excluded, under s. 167(3), from filing a complaint, and requested that the adjudicator dismiss the complaint for lack of jurisdiction. The adjudicator decided that he had jurisdiction, having found that Torre's role was more similar to that of a supervisor. The Bank applied for judicial review.
The Federal Court dismissed the application. The Bank did not satisfy the court that the adjudicator had committed a reviewable error.
Labour Law - Topic 576
Labour relations boards and judicial review - Judicial review - General - Standard of review - A major bank sought judicial review of an interlocutory decision by an adjudicator that he had jurisdiction to hear a complaint for unjust dismissal filed by a "manager" employee under s. 240 of the Canada Labour Code - The Federal Court stated that "[i]n practice, the judgment of the Supreme Court of Canada in Dunsmuir v. New Brunswick, 2008 SCC 9 ... did not substantially change the applicable standard of review for decisions made by an adjudicator appointed under the Code ... In fact, the privative clauses [at ss. 243(2) and 251.12(7)] for unjust dismissals and monetary claims, and the purpose and expertise of the adjudicator or referee continue to command a very high degree of deference. Overall, for questions of fact, this Court will intervene only if the tribunal based its decision on an erroneous finding of fact that was made in a perverse or capricious manner, or if the decision was made without regard for the material before it" - See paragraphs 6 to 8.
Labour Law - Topic 576
Labour relations boards and judicial review - Judicial review - General - Standard of review - Section 240(1) of the Canada Labour Code permitted complaints of unjust dismissal by employees, excluding "managers" (s. 167(3)) - The Federal Court stated that "[w]hen considered separately, an adjudicator's legal interpretation of the term 'manager' used in subsection 167(3) of the Code, may give rise to a question of law reviewable according to the standard of correctness. However, in practice, the determination made by the same adjudicator following an exhaustive analysis of the evidence in the record that a person does or does not hold a position of manager must be dealt with as a question of mixed law and fact. In general, an issue of mixed law and fact is reviewed according to the same standard that applies to questions of fact, which are usually reviewed on the basis of reasonableness" - The leading jurisprudence emphasized the need to review the impugned decision on the basis of the conclusions of fact and the overall reasoning of the tribunal - See paragraphs 9 to 11.
Labour Law - Topic 579
Labour relations boards and judicial review - Judicial review - General - Preliminary or interlocutory decisions and orders - [See first Labour Law - Topic 576 ].
Labour Law - Topic 6004
Industrial relations - Manager defined - In the context of a judicial review application, the Federal Court stated that "[c]onsidering that the word 'manager' [used in s. 167(3) of the Canada Labour Code] is not defined by Parliament, case law has remedied this shortcoming by enumerating a certain number of relevant criteria or factors to be considered to determine in which cases an employee holds or does not hold a position of manager ... The Federal Court of Appeal has noted on several occasions that the word 'manager' in subsection 167(3) had to have a narrow meaning because this provision 'subtracts employees who are "manager" from the body of persons enjoying that right' ... 'The fundamental test is whether that person had significant autonomy, discretion, and authority in the conduct of the business of the employer'" - See paragraphs 13 to 17.
Labour Law - Topic 6004
Industrial relations - Manager defined - An employee was dismissed by her employer, a major bank - She held a position as manager - The employee filed a complaint for unjust dismissal under s. 240 of the Canada Labour Code - An adjudicator dismissed the employer's preliminary objection that the employee was a "manager" and therefore excluded from filing a complaint (s. 167(3)) - The Federal Court stated the adjudicator was warranted in examining the tasks performed by the employee - Other important contextual factors were the special nature of the employer's banking activities, the size of the organization and the scope of the employee's authority where she performed her duties (a banking centre) - "In fact, as has been underlined in abundant case law of this Court or adjudicators ... it is not necessary that the independence of the person filing a complaint for dismissal be '... absolute in order to be considered a "manager", even in the "narrow" sense of subsection 167(3)'" - See paragraph 19.
Labour Law - Topic 6036
Industrial relations - Complaints - Unjust dismissal - Exceptions - Managers - An adjudicator made an interlocutory decision to the effect that he had jurisdiction to hear a complaint for unjust dismissal filed by a bank manager employee under s. 240 of the Canada Labour Code - At issue on the judicial review application was the reasonableness of the adjudicator's conclusions that the employee was not a "manager" within the meaning of s. 167(3) of the Code, but held a supervisory position - The Federal Court held that the conclusions reached by the adjudicator were reasonable and were defensible according to the evidence in the record - The adjudicator's general approach was not inconsistent with the principles previously enumerated by the court - Finally, after reviewing the evidence, the adjudicator could reasonably conclude that the employee held a "supervisory" position rather than a "managerial" position - An adjudicator's decision must be read as a whole - "Considering the applicable standard of review in this case [reasonableness] it is not appropriate to conduct a micro-analysis of each of the adjudicator's conclusions" - The adjudicator's reasons were not perverse or made in a capricious manner - In the end result, the adjudicator had jurisdiction to hear the complaint - See paragraphs 20 to 30.
Labour Law - Topic 6036
Industrial relations - Complaints - Unjust dismissal - Exceptions - Managers - An employee, a bank manager, filed a complaint for unjust dismissal under s. 240 of the Canada Labour Code - The adjudicator dismissed the bank's preliminary objection that he did not have jurisdiction to hear the complaint because the employee was a "manager" and therefore excluded from filing a complaint (s. 167(3)) - The bank applied for judicial review - The Federal Court dismissed the application, because the bank did not satisfy the court that the adjudicator had committed a reviewable error - The issue "was not to determine whether there are more adjudicators who consider that a manager of a Banking Centre is a 'manager' within the meaning of subsection 167(3) of the Code ... [E]ach case must be decided on its own facts ... In this case, the adjudicator could reasonably conclude on the basis of the evidence in the record that the [employee] had little independence in practice; she would comply with the Bank's directives concerning discipline, hiring, dismissal, preparing schedules and establishing salaries so that the branch's objectives were met by the staff in office. Accordingly, the [employee's] role was much more similar to that of a supervisor than that of a 'manager'" - The adjudicator therefore had jurisdiction to hear the complaint - See paragraph 32.
Labour Law - Topic 6045
Industrial relations - Complaints - Adjudicators - Jurisdiction - [See both Labour Law - Topic 6036 ].
Cases Noticed:
New Brunswick (Board of Management) v. Dunsmuir (2008), 372 N.R. 1; 329 N.B.R.(2d) 1; 844 A.P.R. 1; 2008 SCC 9, refd to. [para. 6].
Deschênes v. Canadian Imperial Bank of Commerce (2009), 359 F.T.R. 148; 2009 FC 799, refd to. [para. 6].
Alberta Union of Provincial Employees et al. v. Lethbridge Community College (2004), 319 N.R. 201; 348 A.R. 1; 321 W.A.C. 1; 2004 SCC 28, refd to. [para. 7].
Bitton v. HSBC Bank Canada (2006), 303 F.T.R. 72; 2006 FC 1347, refd to. [para. 7].
Khosa v. Canada (Minister of Citizenship and Immigration) (2009), 385 N.R. 206; 2009 SCC 12, refd to. [para. 8].
Democracy Watch v. Campbell et al. (2009), 387 N.R. 261; 2009 FCA 79, refd to. [para. 10].
Lee-Shanok v. Banca Nazionale Del Lavoro of Canada Ltd., [1987] 3 F.C. 578; 76 N.R. 359 (F.C.A.), refd to. [para. 15].
Canada (Attorney General) v. Gautier, [1980] 2 F.C. 393; 34 N.R. 549 (F.C.A.), refd to. [para. 15].
Avalon Aviation Ltd. v. Desgagne (1981), 42 N.R. 337 (F.C.A.), refd to. [para. 15].
Msuya v. Sundance Balloons International Ltd. (2006), 289 F.T.R. 85; 2006 FC 321, refd to. [para. 16].
Isaac v. Listuguj Mi'gmaq First Nation, [2004] C.L.A.D. No. 287, appld. [para. 16].
Canadian Imperial Bank of Commerce v. Bateman, [1991] 3 F.C. 586; 42 F.T.R. 218 (T.D.), refd to. [para. 19].
Fox v. Bank of Nova Scotia, [2002] C.L.A.D. No. 552, refd to. [para. 31].
Normandeau v. National Bank of Canada, [1996] C.L.A.D. No. 712, refd to. [para. 31].
Rollingson v. Royal Bank of Canada, [2003] C.L.A.D. No. 223, refd to. [para. 31].
Shek v. Bank of Nova Scotia, [1996] C.L.A.D. No. 126, refd to. [para. 31].
Statutes Noticed:
Canada Labour Code - see Labour Code.
Labour Code, R.S.C. 1985, c. L-2, sect. 167(3) [para. 3]; sect. 240 [para. 1].
Counsel:
Patrick Galizia, for the applicant;
Dominic Bianco, for the respondent.
Solicitors of Record:
Ogilvy Renault S.E.N.C.R.L., s.r.l, Montreal, Quebec, for the applicant;
Mercadente, Di Pace Avocats, Montreal, Quebec, for the respondent.
This application for judicial review was heard at Montréal, Quebec, on January 12, 2010, by Martineau, J., of the Federal Court, who delivered the following reasons for judgment and judgment, dated January 29, 2010.
Get this document and AI-powered insights with a free trial of vLex and Vincent AI
Get Started for FreeUnlock full access with a free 7-day trial
Transform your legal research with vLex
-
Complete access to the largest collection of common law case law on one platform
-
Generate AI case summaries that instantly highlight key legal issues
-
Advanced search capabilities with precise filtering and sorting options
-
Comprehensive legal content with documents across 100+ jurisdictions
-
Trusted by 2 million professionals including top global firms
-
Access AI-Powered Research with Vincent AI: Natural language queries with verified citations
Unlock full access with a free 7-day trial
Transform your legal research with vLex
-
Complete access to the largest collection of common law case law on one platform
-
Generate AI case summaries that instantly highlight key legal issues
-
Advanced search capabilities with precise filtering and sorting options
-
Comprehensive legal content with documents across 100+ jurisdictions
-
Trusted by 2 million professionals including top global firms
-
Access AI-Powered Research with Vincent AI: Natural language queries with verified citations
Unlock full access with a free 7-day trial
Transform your legal research with vLex
-
Complete access to the largest collection of common law case law on one platform
-
Generate AI case summaries that instantly highlight key legal issues
-
Advanced search capabilities with precise filtering and sorting options
-
Comprehensive legal content with documents across 100+ jurisdictions
-
Trusted by 2 million professionals including top global firms
-
Access AI-Powered Research with Vincent AI: Natural language queries with verified citations
Unlock full access with a free 7-day trial
Transform your legal research with vLex
-
Complete access to the largest collection of common law case law on one platform
-
Generate AI case summaries that instantly highlight key legal issues
-
Advanced search capabilities with precise filtering and sorting options
-
Comprehensive legal content with documents across 100+ jurisdictions
-
Trusted by 2 million professionals including top global firms
-
Access AI-Powered Research with Vincent AI: Natural language queries with verified citations
Unlock full access with a free 7-day trial
Transform your legal research with vLex
-
Complete access to the largest collection of common law case law on one platform
-
Generate AI case summaries that instantly highlight key legal issues
-
Advanced search capabilities with precise filtering and sorting options
-
Comprehensive legal content with documents across 100+ jurisdictions
-
Trusted by 2 million professionals including top global firms
-
Access AI-Powered Research with Vincent AI: Natural language queries with verified citations
Start Your 7-day Trial
-
Balzer v. Federated Co-operatives Ltd. et al., (2014) 437 Sask.R. 10 (QB)
...491, refd to. [para. 77]. Hill v. Begg, [1987] S.J. No. 824 (Q.B.), refd to. [para. 77]. Canadian Imperial Bank of Commerce v. Torre (2010), 362 F.T.R. 232; 2010 FC 105, refd to. [para. Brown et al. v. Canadian Imperial Bank of Commerce et al., [2012] O.T.C. Uned. 2377; 2012 ONSC 2377, refd......
-
6245820 Canada Inc. et al. v. Perrella, 2011 FC 728
...Balloons International Ltd. (2006), 289 F.T.R. 85; 2006 FC 321, refd to. [para. 12]. Canadian Imperial Bank of Commerce v. Torre (2010), 362 F.T.R. 232; 2010 FC 105, refd to. [para. 12]. H & R Transport Ltd. v. Baldrey (2005), 334 N.R. 340; 2005 FCA 151, refd to. [para. 13]. Wu v. Royal......
-
Cicale v. Swiss International Air Lines Ltd.
...be considered to determine in which cases an employee holds or not a position of manager (see Canadian Imperial Bank of Commerce v Torre, 2010 FC 105 and case law cited at paras 13-16 [Torre]). Indeed, the word “manager” has a narrow meaning (see Lee-Shanok v Banque Nazionale del Lavoro of ......
-
Spruce Hollow Heavy Haul Ltd. v. Madill
...is more important than the title given to the worker": Canadian Imperial Bank of Commerce v. Torre , [2010] F.C.J. No. 85 at para. 17, 362 F.T.R. 232. [61] The Court went on in Torre to observe that a manager "is a worker who performs administrative rather than operational duties", and that......
-
Balzer v. Federated Co-operatives Ltd. et al., (2014) 437 Sask.R. 10 (QB)
...491, refd to. [para. 77]. Hill v. Begg, [1987] S.J. No. 824 (Q.B.), refd to. [para. 77]. Canadian Imperial Bank of Commerce v. Torre (2010), 362 F.T.R. 232; 2010 FC 105, refd to. [para. Brown et al. v. Canadian Imperial Bank of Commerce et al., [2012] O.T.C. Uned. 2377; 2012 ONSC 2377, refd......
-
6245820 Canada Inc. et al. v. Perrella, 2011 FC 728
...Balloons International Ltd. (2006), 289 F.T.R. 85; 2006 FC 321, refd to. [para. 12]. Canadian Imperial Bank of Commerce v. Torre (2010), 362 F.T.R. 232; 2010 FC 105, refd to. [para. 12]. H & R Transport Ltd. v. Baldrey (2005), 334 N.R. 340; 2005 FCA 151, refd to. [para. 13]. Wu v. Royal......
-
Cicale v. Swiss International Air Lines Ltd.
...be considered to determine in which cases an employee holds or not a position of manager (see Canadian Imperial Bank of Commerce v Torre, 2010 FC 105 and case law cited at paras 13-16 [Torre]). Indeed, the word “manager” has a narrow meaning (see Lee-Shanok v Banque Nazionale del Lavoro of ......
-
Spruce Hollow Heavy Haul Ltd. v. Madill
...is more important than the title given to the worker": Canadian Imperial Bank of Commerce v. Torre , [2010] F.C.J. No. 85 at para. 17, 362 F.T.R. 232. [61] The Court went on in Torre to observe that a manager "is a worker who performs administrative rather than operational duties", and that......
-
Are Your Managers Really 'Managers' ? The Legal Concept Of 'Manager' Under The Canada Labour Code
...Code sets out minimum employment standards, and a unique unjust dismissal regime that applies only to federally regulated employers. 2 2010 FC 105. 3 The test set out in this article pertains only to the factors considered whether an employee is a manager for the purposes of the Canada Labo......