The Impact of St Catharines Milling
Author | Karen Drake |
Pages | 618-638 |
TheImpactof
St Catharines Milling
Karen Drake*
A. INTRODUCTION
St Catharines Millingmayseemlikeapeculiarchoiceasoneofthethree
constitutionalcasesthathelpedtodeneCanadaasanationgiventhat
mostof t he legal principles armed by Lord Watsonwr iting for the
PrivyCouncilhavebeenoverruledThischapteridentiestheprinci
plesfromSt Catharines Milling whicharestillgoodlawandarguesthat
thelogicthatunderliesandshapesthoseprinciplesisthelogicofthe
doctrineofdiscoveryandtheprincipleofterra nullius
Juristshavearticulateddierentversionsofthedoctrineofdiscovery
anddisagreedaboutitspreciserequirementsAtitsessencethedoctrine
AssociateProfessorOsgoodeHallLawSchoolatYorkUniversityIwouldliketo
thankJessicaKarjanmaaforherdiligentresearchassistanceandKentMcNeilfor
hishelpfulcommentsonanearlierdraftAnyerrorsaremyresponsibilityalone
SeeRobertJMillerTheDoctrineofDiscoveryinRobertJMilleretalDiscovering
IndigenousLandsTheDoctrineofDiscoveryintheEnglishColoniesOxfordOxford
UniversityPressatarguingthatEuropeansoccasionallydisagreed
overtheexactmeaningofDiscoveryandevensometimesviolentlydisputedtheir
divergentclaimsbutoneprincipletheyneverdisagreedaboutwasthattheIn
digenouspeoplesandnationslostsovereigncommercialandrealpropertyrights
immediatelyupontheirdiscoverybyEuropeansSeeKarenDrakeThe A nswer,
NottheProblemAnExaminationoftheRoleofAboriginalRightsinSecuringaLiberal
Foundation for the Legitimacy of th e Canadian StateLLMThesisUniversityofToronto
FacultyofLawunpublishedatidentifyingandanalyzingthreedif
ferentversionsofthedoctrineofdiscovery
The Impact of StCatharinesMilling
allowsanationtoacquiresovereigntyoverforeignterritorybybeingthe
rsttodiscoveritonsomeversionsitwasnecessarytonotonlydiscover
butalsoeectivelyoccupytheterritoryTraditionallythismodeofac
quiringsovereigntyappliedonlytoterra nulliusthatisterritorynotyet
possessedbyasociallyandpoliticallyorganizedcommunitySomeEuro
peannationshoweverdeemedIndigenousterritoriestobeterra nullius
forthesakeofassertingsovereigntyoverthembymeansofdiscovery
TheirrationalewasthesupposedinferiorityofIndigenouspeoples
Theoperationofthedoctrineofdiscoveryandtheprincipleofterra
nulliuswithinSt Catharines MillingisnotimmediatelyapparentNeither
ofthesephrasesappearsinLordWatsonsdecisionNordoeshisdeci
sioncontainanydiscussionofMarshallCJstrilogyestablishingthedoc
trineofdiscoveryinAmericanlawincludingJohnson v M’Intosh,which
hasbeencitedatlengthinmodernCanadiandecisionsNordidLord
WatsonexplicitlyaccuseIndigenouspeoplesofinferiorityasChancellor
BoyddidsoopenlyinthetrialdecisionYetasothershaverecognized
thedoctrineofdiscoveryisenmeshedwithinLordWatsonsanalysis
Canadahasmanythingstobeproudofduringitssesquicentennial
butthedoctrineofdiscoveryisnotoneofthemWhileCanadiansright
fullycelebrateourmanyaccomplishmentsthedoctrineofdiscoveryre
mainsournationalshameThisstateofaairsisnotunavoidableOur
elected governments haveit wit hin their power to repudiate the doc
SeeJohnHCurriePublic Internati onal LawdedTorontoIrwinLawat
SeeCurrieibidDrakeabovenoteat
SeeMillerabovenoteat
Ibid atMFLindleyTheAcquisitionandGovernmentofBackwardTerritoryinInterna-
tionalLawBeingaTreatiseontheLawandPracticeRelatingtoColonialExpansionNew
YorkNegroUniversitiesPressatJohnson v M’Intosh Wheaton
atUS
Johnson v M’Intoshibid
SeeespeciallyGuerin v CanadaSCRatDicksonJGuerinR v Van
der Pee tSCRatparasandLamerCJMitchell v Canada (Minister
of National Revenue)SCCatparasBinnieJminorityopinionSee
also R v SparrowSCRatSparrowholdingthattherewasfrom
theoutsetneveranydoubtthatsovereigntyandlegislativepowerandindeedthe
underlyingtitletosuchlandsvestedintheCrownandcitingJo hnson v M’Intosh
abovenoteassupportforthispropositionTsilhqotinNationvBritishColumbia
BCCAatpara
R v St Catharines Milling and Lumber CompanyORChSt Catharines
Milling TrialDecision
SeeLeroyLileBearAConceptofNativeTitleTheLegalTermsintheBale
forLandSummerAwkesasne NotesTraceyLindbergTheDoctrineof
DiscoveryinCanadainRobertJMilleretalabovenoteat
Get this document and AI-powered insights with a free trial of vLex and Vincent AI
Get Started for FreeUnlock full access with a free 7-day trial
Transform your legal research with vLex
-
Complete access to the largest collection of common law case law on one platform
-
Generate AI case summaries that instantly highlight key legal issues
-
Advanced search capabilities with precise filtering and sorting options
-
Comprehensive legal content with documents across 100+ jurisdictions
-
Trusted by 2 million professionals including top global firms
-
Access AI-Powered Research with Vincent AI: Natural language queries with verified citations

Unlock full access with a free 7-day trial
Transform your legal research with vLex
-
Complete access to the largest collection of common law case law on one platform
-
Generate AI case summaries that instantly highlight key legal issues
-
Advanced search capabilities with precise filtering and sorting options
-
Comprehensive legal content with documents across 100+ jurisdictions
-
Trusted by 2 million professionals including top global firms
-
Access AI-Powered Research with Vincent AI: Natural language queries with verified citations

Unlock full access with a free 7-day trial
Transform your legal research with vLex
-
Complete access to the largest collection of common law case law on one platform
-
Generate AI case summaries that instantly highlight key legal issues
-
Advanced search capabilities with precise filtering and sorting options
-
Comprehensive legal content with documents across 100+ jurisdictions
-
Trusted by 2 million professionals including top global firms
-
Access AI-Powered Research with Vincent AI: Natural language queries with verified citations

Unlock full access with a free 7-day trial
Transform your legal research with vLex
-
Complete access to the largest collection of common law case law on one platform
-
Generate AI case summaries that instantly highlight key legal issues
-
Advanced search capabilities with precise filtering and sorting options
-
Comprehensive legal content with documents across 100+ jurisdictions
-
Trusted by 2 million professionals including top global firms
-
Access AI-Powered Research with Vincent AI: Natural language queries with verified citations

Unlock full access with a free 7-day trial
Transform your legal research with vLex
-
Complete access to the largest collection of common law case law on one platform
-
Generate AI case summaries that instantly highlight key legal issues
-
Advanced search capabilities with precise filtering and sorting options
-
Comprehensive legal content with documents across 100+ jurisdictions
-
Trusted by 2 million professionals including top global firms
-
Access AI-Powered Research with Vincent AI: Natural language queries with verified citations
