Trang et al. v. Edmonton Remand Centre (Director) et al.

JurisdictionAlberta
CourtCourt of Queen's Bench of Alberta (Canada)
JudgeMarceau, J.
Citation2006 ABQB 834,(2006), 407 A.R. 328 (QB)
Date08 June 2004

Trang v. Edmonton Remand Centre (2006), 407 A.R. 328 (QB)

MLB headnote and full text

Temp. Cite: [2006] A.R. TBEd. DE.015

De Trang, Binh Quoc Trang, Cuong Quoc Trang, Thao Mai Dao, James Edward Mah, Man Kit Chan, Alex Hang Chan, Donald Cheung, Vi Quoc Trang, Tien Lai Lam, Long Nguyen, Jerry Nguyen, Thi Hoang Le, Joseph Vincent Kochan, Anh Le Tran, Josephine Soo Yun Voon, Hiep Quang Le, Rocky Allan Simmons, Phong Huy Tran, Adrian Tiburico Vergara, Vu Hang Trinh, Helen Hoang Nguyen, Boa Minh Tran and Willy T. Lau (applicants) v. The Director of the Edmonton Remand Centre (respondent) and Her Majesty The Queen in Right of Canada (third party)

(016033268U1; 2006 ABQB 834)

Indexed As: Trang et al. v. Edmonton Remand Centre (Director) et al.

Alberta Court of Queen's Bench

Judicial District of Edmonton

Marceau, J.

November 20, 2006.

Summary:

Inmates alleged that the unsafe conditions in which they were transported by the Edmonton Remand Centre and Court and Prisoner Services violated their rights under ss. 7 and 12 of the Charter of Rights and Freedoms.

The Alberta Court of Queen's Bench held that the transportation conditions did not constitute cruel and unusual treatment or punishment (s. 12), but did violate their s. 7 Charter right to life, liberty and security of the person. Given the state's arbitrary and irrational policies respecting prisoner transportation, the deprivation of that right was not in accordance with the principles of fundamental justice. The court determined what exact conditions violated s. 7 and suggested what improved transportation conditions might be necessary to avoid a further s. 7 challenge.

Civil Rights - Topic 201

Life - General - [See Civil Rights - Topic 1369.3 ].

Civil Rights - Topic 1369.3

Security of the person - Institutional inmates - Transportation - Inmates alleged that the conditions in which they were transported between remand centres, institutions, court appearances, medical appointments, etc., violated their s. 7 Charter right to life, liberty and security of the person - Particularly, the inmates complained that their physical and psychological well-being was jeopardized by the use of handcuffs and shackles in the unpadded, cramped interior compartments of the vans used - The ceilings were low, there were no hand holds, no impact resistant barriers, the unpadded metal seats were sideways instead of front-facing and there were no seat belts - The inmates complained that they were shackled so close together that they could not adjust their seating positions to get comfortable - In the event of a crash, the inmates were trapped until the doors were unlocked from the outside - The Alberta Court of Queen's Bench held that the transport conditions violated the inmates' right to life, liberty and security of the person contrary to the principles of fundamental justice - Mere inmate discomfort did not trigger s. 7, because "serious psychological and physical suffering" was required - The state's approach to inmate transportation was arbitrary and irrational - Although the objective of public safety through securing inmates and ensuring officer safety was valid, that had to be balanced with the state's obligation respecting inmate safety and comfort, which was virtually ignored - The court determined what vehicle deficiencies threatened inmate life and security of the person interests and stated that "if the [state] do not undertake a serious analysis of the practicality of installing handholds or front-facing, impact-resistant seat backs, and an impact resistant barrier for the inmates at the front of the cage, they will be facing another application ..." - See paragraphs 93 to 153.

Civil Rights - Topic 3828.5

Cruel and unusual treatment or punishment - What constitutes - Prisoners - Transportation - Inmates alleged that the conditions in which they were transported between remand centres, institutions, court appearances, medical appointments, etc., constituted cruel and unusual treatment or punishment contrary to s. 12 of the Charter - Particularly, the inmates complained that their physical and psychological well-being was jeopardized by the use of handcuffs and shackles in the unpadded, cramped interior compartments of the vans used - The ceilings were low, there were no hand holds, no impact resistant barriers, the unpadded metal seats were sideways instead of front-facing and there were no seat belts - The inmates complained that they were shackled so close together that they could not adjust their seating positions to get comfortable - In the event of a crash, the inmates were trapped until the doors were unlocked from the outside - The Alberta Court of Queen's Bench held that the transport conditions did not violate s. 12 of the Charter, stating that "there is no evidence that the transportation conditions meet this test; they are not so excessive that they outrage standards of decency, nor are they grossly disproportionate" - See paragraphs 71 to 73.

Civil Rights - Topic 8344

Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms - Application - Exceptions - Principles of fundamental justice (Charter, s. 7) - [See Civil Rights - Topic 1369.3 ].

Civil Rights - Topic 8467

Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms - Interpretation - Interrelationship among Charter rights - The Alberta Court of Queen's Bench held that a finding that the conditions in which inmates were transported did not constitute cruel and unusual treatment or punishment (Charter, s. 12) did not preclude a finding that the inmates' s. 7 right to life, liberty and security of the person was violated - Rights under s. 12 informed, but did not limit, the content of s. 7 - The court stated that "a s. 7 analysis is not redundant here as the context is different. While both ss. 7 and 12 deal with the same interests (life, liberty and security of the person), further principles of fundamental justice are implicated beyond proportionality and whether a punishment 'shocks the conscience'" - See paragraphs 74 to 92.

Civil Rights - Topic 8547

Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms - Interpretation - Particular words and phrases - Principles of fundamental justice - The Alberta Court of Queen's Bench referred to three criteria for determining what constituted a principle of fundamental justice: "1. A legal principle; 2. there must be a consensus that the alleged principle is 'vital or fundamental to our societal notion of justice'; and 3. The alleged principle must be able to be precisely identified and applied." - Falling within those criteria was the principle that government action could not be arbitrary or irrational - See paragraphs 126 to 127.

Prisons - Topic 1026.1

Administration - Powers re prisoners - Transportation of - [See Civil Rights - Topic 1369.3 and Civil Rights - Topic 3828.5 ].

Cases Noticed:

Stinson Estate v. British Columbia et al. (1999), 133 B.C.A.C. 15; 217 W.A.C. 15; 182 D.L.R.(4th) 407; 1999 BCCA 761, leave to appeal refused (2000), 264 N.R. 394; 152 B.C.A.C. 319; 250 W.A.C. 319 (S.C.C.), refd to. [para. 8].

Wilson v. Canada et al., [1996] B.C.T.C. Uned. 857; 25 B.C.L.R.(3d) 181 (S.C.), refd to. [para. 8].

R. v. Wiles (P.N.), [2005] 3 S.C.R. 895; 343 N.R. 201; 240 N.S.R.(2d) 1; 763 A.P.R. 1; 2005 SCC 84, refd to. [para. 72].

R. v. Malmo-Levine (D.) et al., [2003] 3 S.C.R. 571; 314 N.R. 1; 191 B.C.A.C. 1; 314 W.A.C. 1, refd to. [para. 75].

Reference Re Section 94(2) of the Motor Vehicle Act (B.C.), [1985] 2 S.C.R. 486; 63 N.R. 266, refd to. [para. 76].

Thomson Newspapers Ltd. v. Director of Investigation and Research, Combines Investigation Act et al., [1990] 1 S.C.R. 425; 106 N.R. 161; 39 O.A.C. 161, refd to. [para. 77].

R. v. M.B.P., [1994] 1 S.C.R. 555; 165 N.R. 321; 70 O.A.C. 161, refd to. [para. 77].

R. v. Jones (S.), [1994] 2 S.C.R. 229; 166 N.R. 321; 43 B.C.A.C. 241; 69 W.A.C. 241, refd to. [para. 77].

R. v. White (J.K.), [1999] 2 S.C.R. 417; 240 N.R. 1; 123 B.C.A.C. 161; 201 W.A.C. 161, refd to. [para. 77].

R. v. Jarvis (W.J.), [2002] 3 S.C.R. 757; 295 N.R. 201; 317 A.R. 1; 284 W.A.C. 1, refd to. [para. 77].

R. v. Henry (D.B.) et al., [2005] 3 S.C.R. 609; 342 N.R. 259; 376 A.R. 1; 360 W.A.C. 1; 219 B.C.A.C. 1; 361 W.A.C. 1, refd to. [para. 78].

R. v. Schmidt - see Schmidt v. Canada et al.

Schmidt v. Canada et al., [1987] 1 S.C.R. 500; 76 N.R. 12; 20 O.A.C. 161, refd to. [para. 78].

United States of America v. Allard and Charette, [1987] 1 S.C.R. 564; 75 N.R. 260, refd to. [para. 78].

Kindler v. Canada (Minister of Justice), [1991] 2 S.C.R. 779; 129 N.R. 81, refd to. [para. 78].

United States of America v. Burns and Rafay, [2001] 1 S.C.R. 283; 265 N.R. 212; 148 B.C.A.C. 1; 243 W.A.C. 1, refd to. [para. 80].

R. v. Smith (E.D.), [1987] 1 S.C.R. 1045; 75 N.R. 321, refd to. [para. 82].

R. v. Ferguson (M.E.) (2006), 397 A.R. 1; 384 W.A.C. 1; 2006 ABCA 261, leave to appeal refused [2006] S.C.C.A. No. 121, refd to. [para. 83].

Chiarelli v. Minister of Employment and Immigration, [1992] 1 S.C.R. 711; 135 N.R. 161, refd to. [para. 86].

Rodriguez v. British Columbia (Attorney General) et al., [1993] 3 S.C.R. 519; 158 N.R. 1; 34 B.C.A.C. 1; 56 W.A.C. 1, refd to. [para. 87].

Dumas v. National Parole Board, [1986] 2 S.C.R. 459; 72 N.R. 61, refd to. [para. 90].

Cunningham v. Canada, [1993] 2 S.C.R. 143; 151 N.R. 161; 62 O.A.C. 243, refd to. [para. 90].

May et al. v. Ferndale Institution et al., [2005] 3 S.C.R. 809; 343 N.R. 69; 220 B.C.A.C. 1; 362 W.A.C. 1, refd to. [para. 90].

R. v. Rogers - see R. v. Jackpine (R.).

R. v. Jackpine (R.), [2006] 1 S.C.R. 554; 347 N.R. 201; 210 O.A.C. 200, refd to. [para. 91].

R. v. Morgentaler, [1988] 1 S.C.R. 30; 82 N.R. 1; 26 O.A.C. 1, refd to. [para. 95].

R. v. Parker (T.) (2000), 135 O.A.C. 1; 188 D.L.R.(4th) 385 (C.A.), refd to. [para. 95].

New Brunswick (Minister of Health and Community Services) v. J.G. and D.V., [1999] 3 S.C.R. 46; 244 N.R. 276; 216 N.B.R.(2d) 25; 552 A.P.R. 25, refd to. [para. 96].

Chaoulli v. Quebec (Attorney General) (2005), 335 N.R. 25 (S.C.C.), refd to. [para. 97].

R. v. Stillman (W.W.D.), [1997] 1 S.C.R. 607; 209 N.R. 81; 185 N.B.R.(2d) 1; 472 A.P.R. 1, refd to. [para. 97].

R. v. Gamble - see Gamble v. R.

Gamble v. R., [1988] 2 S.C.R. 595; 89 N.R. 161; 31 O.A.C. 81, refd to. [para. 98].

R. v. Chan (N.C.) (2005), 387 A.R. 123; 2005 ABQB 615, refd to. [para. 99].

Medovarski v. Canada (Ministre de la Citoyenneté et de l'Immigration) (2005), 339 N.R. 1; 2005 SCC 51, refd to. [para. 124].

Canadian Foundation for Children, Youth and the Law v. Canada (Attorney General), [2004] 1 S.C.R. 76; 315 N.R. 201; 183 O.A.C. 1, refd to. [para. 126].

Roncarelli v. Duplessis, [1959] S.C.R. 121, refd to. [para. 128].

Heller v. Martens et al., [2000] A.J. No. 1678 (Q.B.), affd. (2002), 303 A.R. 84; 273 W.A.C. 84; 213 D.L.R.(4th) 124; 2002 ABCA 122, refd to. [para. 147].

Philip v. Hironaka (1997), 210 A.R. 1; 55 Alta. L.R.(3d) 224 (Q.B.), refd to. [para. 147].

Counsel:

T.M. Engel and Nathan J. Whitling, for the applicants;

P.J. Faulds, Q.C., G.A. Harding, Q.C., and S.E. Carey, for the respondent.

This application was heard between June 8, 2004, and June 29, 2006, before Marceau, J., of the Alberta Court of Queen's Bench, Judicial District of Edmonton, who delivered the followng judgment on November 20, 2006.

Get this document and AI-powered insights with a free trial of vLex and Vincent AI

Get Started for Free

Unlock full access with a free 7-day trial

Transform your legal research with vLex

  • Complete access to the largest collection of common law case law on one platform

  • Generate AI case summaries that instantly highlight key legal issues

  • Advanced search capabilities with precise filtering and sorting options

  • Comprehensive legal content with documents across 100+ jurisdictions

  • Trusted by 2 million professionals including top global firms

  • Access AI-Powered Research with Vincent AI: Natural language queries with verified citations

vLex

Unlock full access with a free 7-day trial

Transform your legal research with vLex

  • Complete access to the largest collection of common law case law on one platform

  • Generate AI case summaries that instantly highlight key legal issues

  • Advanced search capabilities with precise filtering and sorting options

  • Comprehensive legal content with documents across 100+ jurisdictions

  • Trusted by 2 million professionals including top global firms

  • Access AI-Powered Research with Vincent AI: Natural language queries with verified citations

vLex

Unlock full access with a free 7-day trial

Transform your legal research with vLex

  • Complete access to the largest collection of common law case law on one platform

  • Generate AI case summaries that instantly highlight key legal issues

  • Advanced search capabilities with precise filtering and sorting options

  • Comprehensive legal content with documents across 100+ jurisdictions

  • Trusted by 2 million professionals including top global firms

  • Access AI-Powered Research with Vincent AI: Natural language queries with verified citations

vLex

Unlock full access with a free 7-day trial

Transform your legal research with vLex

  • Complete access to the largest collection of common law case law on one platform

  • Generate AI case summaries that instantly highlight key legal issues

  • Advanced search capabilities with precise filtering and sorting options

  • Comprehensive legal content with documents across 100+ jurisdictions

  • Trusted by 2 million professionals including top global firms

  • Access AI-Powered Research with Vincent AI: Natural language queries with verified citations

vLex

Unlock full access with a free 7-day trial

Transform your legal research with vLex

  • Complete access to the largest collection of common law case law on one platform

  • Generate AI case summaries that instantly highlight key legal issues

  • Advanced search capabilities with precise filtering and sorting options

  • Comprehensive legal content with documents across 100+ jurisdictions

  • Trusted by 2 million professionals including top global firms

  • Access AI-Powered Research with Vincent AI: Natural language queries with verified citations

vLex

Unlock full access with a free 7-day trial

Transform your legal research with vLex

  • Complete access to the largest collection of common law case law on one platform

  • Generate AI case summaries that instantly highlight key legal issues

  • Advanced search capabilities with precise filtering and sorting options

  • Comprehensive legal content with documents across 100+ jurisdictions

  • Trusted by 2 million professionals including top global firms

  • Access AI-Powered Research with Vincent AI: Natural language queries with verified citations

vLex
7 practice notes
  • Trang et al. v. Edmonton Remand Centre (Director) et al.
    • Canada
    • Court of Queen's Bench of Alberta (Canada)
    • January 8, 2010
    ... " ERC - Warden's Court ") and whether the methods of transportation used to transport prisoners around the province were constitutional (407 A.R. 328; 2006 ABQB 834 - " ERC - Transportation "). In the first case, I concluded that the impugned disciplinary boards failed to meet the requir......
  • Trang et al. v. Edmonton Remand Centre (Director) et al.
    • Canada
    • Court of Appeal (Alberta)
    • August 16, 2007
    ...violated their rights under ss. 7 and 12 of the Charter of Rights and Freedoms. The Alberta Court of Queen's Bench, in a judgment reported 407 A.R. 328; 2006 ABQB 834 , held that the transportation conditions did not constitute cruel and unusual treatment or punishment (s. 12), but did vio......
  • Calgary Board of Education v. Information and Privacy Commissioner (Alta.)
    • Canada
    • Court of Queen's Bench of Alberta (Canada)
    • October 4, 2012
    ...[2002] A.R. Uned. 188; 53 W.C.B.(2d) 477; 2002 ABQB 357, refd to. [para. 32]. Trang et al. v. Edmonton Remand Centre (Director) et al. (2006), 407 A.R. 328; 2006 ABQB 834, revd. (2007), 412 A.R. 215; 404 W.A.C. 215; 2007 ABCA 263, refd to. [para. G.S. Solomon, Q.C., for the applicant on thi......
  • R. v. McCargar (E.G.)
    • Canada
    • Court of Queen's Bench of Alberta (Canada)
    • January 19, 2007
    ...et al., [1990] 1 S.C.R. 425; 106 N.R. 161; 39 O.A.C. 161, refd to. [para. 8]. Trang et al. v. Edmonton Remand Centre (Director) et al. (2006), 407 A.R. 328; 2006 ABQB 834, refd to. [para. 8]. R. v. Mann (P.H.), [2004] 3 S.C.R. 59; 324 N.R. 215; 187 Man.R.(2d) 1; 330 W.A.C. 1; 241 D.L.R.(4th......
  • Get Started for Free
7 cases
  • Trang et al. v. Edmonton Remand Centre (Director) et al.
    • Canada
    • Court of Queen's Bench of Alberta (Canada)
    • January 8, 2010
    ... " ERC - Warden's Court ") and whether the methods of transportation used to transport prisoners around the province were constitutional (407 A.R. 328; 2006 ABQB 834 - " ERC - Transportation "). In the first case, I concluded that the impugned disciplinary boards failed to meet the requir......
  • Trang et al. v. Edmonton Remand Centre (Director) et al.
    • Canada
    • Court of Appeal (Alberta)
    • August 16, 2007
    ...violated their rights under ss. 7 and 12 of the Charter of Rights and Freedoms. The Alberta Court of Queen's Bench, in a judgment reported 407 A.R. 328; 2006 ABQB 834 , held that the transportation conditions did not constitute cruel and unusual treatment or punishment (s. 12), but did vio......
  • R. v. McCargar (E.G.), 2007 ABQB 30
    • Canada
    • Court of Queen's Bench of Alberta (Canada)
    • January 19, 2007
    ...et al., [1990] 1 S.C.R. 425; 106 N.R. 161; 39 O.A.C. 161, refd to. [para. 8]. Trang et al. v. Edmonton Remand Centre (Director) et al. (2006), 407 A.R. 328; 2006 ABQB 834, refd to. [para. 8]. R. v. Mann (P.H.), [2004] 3 S.C.R. 59; 324 N.R. 215; 187 Man.R.(2d) 1; 330 W.A.C. 1; 241 D.L.R.(4th......
  • Calgary Board of Education v. Information and Privacy Commissioner (Alta.), 2013 ABQB 187
    • Canada
    • Court of Queen's Bench of Alberta (Canada)
    • October 4, 2012
    ...[2002] A.R. Uned. 188; 53 W.C.B.(2d) 477; 2002 ABQB 357, refd to. [para. 32]. Trang et al. v. Edmonton Remand Centre (Director) et al. (2006), 407 A.R. 328; 2006 ABQB 834, revd. (2007), 412 A.R. 215; 404 W.A.C. 215; 2007 ABCA 263, refd to. [para. G.S. Solomon, Q.C., for the applicant on thi......
  • Get Started for Free