Apprenticeship ratios a struggle for Ontario contractors; Restrictions are feeding labour shortages, experts say.

• Author: Stewart, Nick
• Position: NEWS

While he faces many difficulties in growing his contracting firm, Kenora's Gregg Bowman says that Ontario's restrictive apprenticeship ratios in particular are choking his ability to expand.

[ILLUSTRATION OMITTED]

"It's a massive restriction for guys like me," says Bowman, who has led the long-time family-owned Bowman Electric for the last 12 years.

"The people in Ottawa need to recognize what this means and that it needs to change."

Across Canada, provincial governments require that business have a set number of journeymen on hand for every apprentice that is to be trained. For most Ontario trades, this typically means a ratio of three to one, or three journeymen for each apprentice.

However, given the worsening shortage of skilled labour throughout the province, many businesses - including Bowman Electric--are struggling just to stay staffed. This puts considerable strain on being able to remain in business, let alone maintain the staff ratios needed to bring new apprentices into the fold, he says.

As a result, the influx of new apprentices into both the individual business and the workforce in general is being severely hampered, he argues.

He points to his own business as a key example, estimating that he's already turning down 200 people a year interested in signing up as apprentices.

Part of the problem are some large corporations who have no apprenticeship programs but often require journeymen. This means that these individuals are often poached rather than brought up through the ranks as an apprentice, placing even further strain on the ability of small business to maintain staff.

For Bowman, this has become a particularly big problem in the last year as the mining and oil industries poached his journeymen, bringing his staff levels from 25 to 14.

The idea of changing apprenticeship ratios isn't without recent precedent. Last fall, the provincial government quietly changed the ratio of journeyman-to-apprentice ratio for brick and stone masons from five-to-one to three-to-one. Similarly, workers in the architectural glass and metal trade, such as construction boilermakers and ironworkers, also saw a change from four-to-one to two-to-one. All other trades, however, remain unchanged.

Ontario is one of the few jurisdictions in Canada which still features ratios beyond one-to-one. In British Columbia, apprenticeship ratios have been relaxed entirely in some sectors in light of the run up to the 2010 Olympic Games.

Conversely, Ontario's...