Table of Cases

• Author: John D. McCamus
• Pages: 1174-1265

1174

TABLE OF CASES

0624708 BC Ltd v Wallace, 2011 BCSC 13 .......................................................10 96

0856464 BC Ltd v Timb erWest Forest Corp, 2014 BCSC 2433 ..................14 7, 160

0930032 BC Ltd v 3 Oaks Dai ry Farms Ltd, 2015 BCCA 332 ......................80 6–7

100 Main Street Ltd v W B Sullivan Construction Lt d (1978),

20 OR (2d) 401, 88 DLR (3d) 1 (CA), leave to appeal to

SCC refused (1978), 20 OR (2d) 401n, 88 DLR (3d) 1n,

24 NR 359n (SCC) ......................................................................775, 929, 1027

1043545 Ontario Inc v 2748355 Canada Inc, [1998] OJ No 2781,

70 OTC 267, 19 RPR (3d) 190 (Gen Div) .....................................................816

1092369 Alberta Ltd v Joben I nvestments Ltd, 2013 ABQB 310 .......................783

1110049 Ontario Ltd v Exclusive D iamonds Inc (1995),

25 OR (3d) 417, [1995] OJ No 2690, 83 OAC 391 (CA) ...................1091, 111 5

1174538 Ontario Ltd v Ba rzel Windsor (1984) Inc,

[1999] OJ No 5091, 28 RPR (3d) 256 (SCJ) ..............................................10 95

1193430 Ontario Inc v Boa-Franc (1983) Ltée (2003),

68 OR (3d) 382, [2003] OJ No 5138, [2003] OTC 1103 (SCJ),

rev’d (sub nom 1193430 Ontar io Inc v Boa Franc Inc) (2005),

78 OR (3d) 81, 260 DLR (4th) 659, [2005] OJ No 4671 (CA) .....................729

1247532 Albert a Ltd v Valpy Corp, 2007 ABQ B 547 ......................................... 196

1539304 Ontario Inc v ICICI Ban k Canada, 2013 ONSC 2737 ......................... 900

1560032 Ontario Ltd v A rcuri, [2006] 212 OAC 95, (2006),

37 BLR (4th) 233 (Ont CA) ........................................................................ 212

2123201 Ontario Inc v Israel Est ate, 2016 ONCA 409 ...................................... 860

2190322 Ontario Ltd v Ajilon Consult ing, 2014 ONSC 21 ........................392 , 964

224981 Ontario Inc v Intac t Insurance Co, 2016 ONSC 642 .............................683

306793 Ontario Ltd v Ri mes (1979), 25 OR (2d) 79,

100 DLR (3d) 350, 10 RPR 257 (CA) ............................................... 104 0, 1123

Table of Cases 1175

3869130 Canada Inc (cob ICB Distr ibution 2001) v ICB

Distribut ion Inc, 2008 ONCA 396 ...............................................................817

473807 Ontario Ltd v The TDL Group Ltd (2006), 271 DLR (4th) 636,

47 RPR (4th) 1, [2006] OJ No 3050 (CA) ....................................................829

514953 BC Ltd v Leung, 2007 BCCA 114 .........................................................1000

702535 Ontario Inc v Lloyd’s London, Non-Marine Unde rwriters (2000),

184 DLR (4th) 687, 130 OAC 373, 2000 CanLII 5684 (Ont CA) ............. 105 9

7326246 Canada Inc v Ajilon Consult ing, 2014 ONCA 28 (Ont Div Ct) .........4 92

771225 Ontario Inc v Bra mco Holdings Co, 1995), 21 OR (3d) 739

(Ont CA) ...................................................................................................... 650

872899 Ontario v I acovoni (1998), 40 OR (3d) 715, 163 DLR

(4th) 263, [1998] OJ No 2797 (CA), aff’g (1997), 33 OR (3d)

561, 147 DLR (4th) 333, [1997] OJ No 1917 (Gen Div),

leave to appeal to t he SCC refused (1999), 236 NR 199,

[1998] SCCA No 476 ............................................................286, 290, 291, 292

947101 Ontario Ltd v Barrhaven Town Centre I nc,

[1995] OJ No 15, 121 DLR (4th) 748, 17 BLR (2d) 186 (Gen Div) ..............944

968703 Ontario Ltd v Vernon (2002), 58 OR (3d) 215,

[2002] OJ No 580, 155 OAC 386 (CA) ........................................................729

978011 Ontario Ltd v Cornell Engi neering Co (2001), 53 OR (3d)

783, 198 DLR (4th) 615, [2001] OJ No 1446 (CA) ...............149, 214, 369, 370

A & BB Rice Inc v Wigmore Far ms Ltd (2005),

2005 Carswel l Ont 7316 (SCJ) ....................................................................6 70

A & K Lick-a-Chick Franch ises Ltd v Cordiv Enterpri ses Ltd

(1981), 44 NSR (2d) 159, 119 DLR (3d) 440, [1981] NSJ

No 335 (TD) .................................................................................467, 496, 844

A Roberts & Co Ltd v L eicestershire County Council,

[1961] Ch 555 ..................................................................................... 646, 648,

A Schroeder Music Publ ishing Co Ltd v MacAulay, [1974]

1 WLR 1308, [1974] 3 All ER 616 (HL) .............................466, 527, 534, 1169

A v Bottril l (2002), [2002] UKPC 44, [2003] 1 AC 449 (PC)........................... 1052

ABB Inc v Domtar Inc, 20 07 SCC 50 .................................................................. 887

Abba Ventures Inc v Royal Trust C orp of Canada (1996),

176 NBR (2d) 33, [1996] NBJ No 131, 25 BLR (2d) 211 (QB) .....................136

Abbot of Westminster v C lerke (1536–37), 1 Dyer 27a, 73 ER 59 (KB) ............ 657

Abel v McDonald, [1964] 2 OR 256, 45 DLR (2d) 198 (CA).............................. 367

Aberdeen City Counc il v Stewart Milne Group Ltd, [2011] UKSC 56 .............. 944

Aberfoyle Plantat ions Ltd v Cheng, [1960] AC 115 (PC) ........................... 770, 771

Abraham v Win gate Properties Ltd (1985), [1986] 1 WWR 568,

[1985] MJ No 156, 36 ManR (2d) 264 (CA) ................................................ 75 6

Abram Steam ship Co v Westvi lle Shipping Co, [1923] AC 773 (HL) .................374

Abrams v Reiac h (Herbert) Ltd, [1922] 1 KB 477 (CA) ..................................... 982

Ackerman v Thoms on & McKinnon, Auch incloss, Kohlmeyer, Inc

(1974), 4 OR (2d) 240, 47 DLR (3d) 524 (CA) ............................................ 190

ACS Public Sector Solutions Inc v Cour thouse Technologies Ltd,

2005 BCCA 605 ........................................................................................... 568

THE LAW OF CONTR ACTS1176

Active Customs Brokers Ltd v S ack, [1987] OJ No 1082, 25 OAC 305,

37 BLR 229 (Div Ct) .................................................................................... 183

Adam v General Pap er Co Ltd (1978), 19 OR (2d) 574,

85 DLR (3d) 736 (HCJ)................................................................................18 8

Adams v Union Cine mas Ltd, [1939] 3 All ER 136 (CA) ................................... 185

Adanac Rea lty Ltd v Homes Development Ltd, [1986] OJ No 1248,

43 RPR 88 (HCJ) .......................................................................................... 415

Adderley v Dixon (1824), 1 Sim & St 607, 57 ER 239 (VC) ..............................1091

Addis v Gramophone Co Ltd, [1909] AC 488 (HL) ..................957, 1047–48, 1053

Addison v Otta wa Auto & Taxi Co (1913), 16 DLR 318 (Ont SCAD) ...............1169

Adolph Lumber Co v Meadowcreek Lu mber Co (1919),

58 SCR 306, 45 DLR 579, [1919] 1 WWR 823 .....................................750, 81 5

Advance Rumely Threshe r Co v Yorga, [1926] SCR 397,

[1926] 3 DLR 517 .........................................................................................538

Afovos Shipping Co SA v Pagn an, [1983] 1 WLR 195 (HL) .............................. 751

Agnew-Surpas s Shoe Stores Ltd v Cummer-Yonge Investments Lt d,

[1976] 2 SCR 221 (SCC) .............................................................................. 818

Agrifood s International Corp v Beat rice Goods Inc, [1997] BCJ No 393,

34 BLR (2d) 294 (SC) .................................................................................. 727

AGT Greenwood Ltd v Desjardi ns — McLeod, 2019 ONCA 158 ......................662

Ahone v Holloway (1988), 30 BCLR (2d) 368, [1988] BCJ No 1603 (CA) ........227

Ailsa Cra ig Fishing Co Ltd v Malvern Fishi ng Co Ltd,

[1983] 1 WLR 964, [1983] 1 All ER 101 (HL) ..............................396, 827, 879

Ainswort h Lumber Co Ltd v KMW Energy Inc, 200 4 BCCA 415 ..................... 715

Aita v Silverstone Towers Ltd (1978), 19 OR (2d) 681,

86 DLR (3d) 439, 4 BLR 92 (CA) ................................................................. 8 31

AL Gullison & Son s Ltd v Corey (1979), 24 NBR (2d) 638,

[1979] NBJ No 49 (QB), rev’d (1980), 29 NBR (2d) 86,

[1980] NBJ No 41 (CA) ................................................................................ 652

Alampi v Swart z, [1964] 1 OR 488, 43 DLR (2d) 11 (CA) .................................808

Alati v Kr uger (1955), 94 CLR 216 (HCA) .........................................................448

Albert E Dan iels Ltd v Sangster (1976), 12 OR (2d) 512 (Co Ct) ...................... 541

Albert v Albe rt (1981), 33 NBR (2d) 689, [1981] NBJ No 60 (QB) ..................... 433

Alberta C aterers Ltd v R Volcan (Alta) Ltd (1977), 10 AR 501,

81 DLR (3d) 672, [1977] AJ No 777 (SCTD) ..............................................1032

Alberta Turkey Producers v L eth Farms Inc (1998), 1998 ABQB 887,

[1999] 7 WWR 12, [1998] AJ No 1187 ........................................................ 5 41

Alderslade v Hendon Lau ndry, Ltd, [1945] KB 189 (CA) .................................. 396

Alec Lobb v Total Oil GB, [1985] 1 All ER 303 (CA) .........................................563

Alessio v Jovic a (1973), 42 DLR (3d) 242, [1974] 2 WWR 126

(Al ta SC AD) ......................................................................................... 3 81, 400

Alevizos v Ni rula, 2003 MBCA 148, 234 DLR (4th) 352, [2003] MJ No 433 ....388

Alexander Ha milton Institute v McNally (1919), 53 NSR 303 (App Div) ..........750

Alexander v R ailway Executive, [1951] 2 KB 882 .............................................. 870

Alexander v R ayson, [1936] 1 KB 169 (CA) ....................................................... 503

Aleyn v Belchie r, (1758) 1 Eden 132, 28 ER 634 .................................90 9, 937, 943