495793 Ontario Ltd. v. Barclay et al., 2016 ONCA 656
| Judge | Juriansz, Epstein and Pepall, JJ.A. |
| Court | Court of Appeal (Ontario) |
| Case Date | March 01, 2016 |
| Jurisdiction | Ontario |
| Citations | 2016 ONCA 656;(2016), 352 O.A.C. 290 (CA) |
495793 Ont. v. Barclay (2016), 352 O.A.C. 290 (CA)
MLB headnote and full text
Temp. Cite: [2016] O.A.C. TBEd. OC.001
495793 Ontario Ltd. c.o.b. as Central Auto Parts and Ricardo P. Mercuri (plaintiffs/respondents) v. Frank Barclay and City of Thunder Bay Police Services Board (defendants/appellants)
(C59053; 2016 ONCA 656)
Indexed As: 495793 Ontario Ltd. v. Barclay et al.
Ontario Court of Appeal
Juriansz, Epstein and Pepall, JJ.A.
September 2, 2016.
Summary:
The plaintiffs sued a police officer (lead investigator) and the City of Thunder Bay Police Services Board (defendants), seeking damages for negligent investigation.
The Ontario Superior Court, in a decision reported 2014 ONSC 3517, allowed the action, and awarded substantial damages. The defendants appealed.
The Ontario Court of Appeal allowed the appeal. The trial judge, inter alia, erred by deciding the content of the standard of care expected of the police without expert evidence. The court, therefore, set aside the trial judge's judgment, except for an award of $70,000 for the loss or property improperly stored by the police.
Police - Topic 5031
Actions against police - Negligence - Conduct of investigation - See paragraphs 45 to 97.
Torts - Topic 48
Negligence - Standard of care - Particular persons and relationships - Police officers - See paragraphs 45 to 97.
Counsel:
C. Kirk Boggs, Jasmine T. Akbarali and David Litwin, for the appellants;
Paul J. Pape and Joanna L. Nairn, for the respondents.
This appeal was heard on March 1, 2016, before Juriansz, Epstein and Pepall, JJ.A., of the Ontario Court of Appeal. The following decision was delivered for the court by Juriansz, J.A., on September 2, 2016.
To continue reading
Request your trial
-
Court Of Appeal Summaries (July 19-23)
...ONCA 425, Payne v. Mak, 2018 ONCA 622, City of Ottawa v. Bentolila, 2006 ONCJ 541, 495793 Ontario Ltd. (Central Auto Parts) v. Barclay, 2016 ONCA 656, Miazga v. Kvello Estate, 2009 SCC 51, Klurfeld v. Nova Quest Logistics Inc., 2016 ONCA 348, Merrifield v. Canada (Attorney General), 2019 ON......
-
Table of cases
...403 495793 Ontario Ltd (Central Auto Parts) v Barclay, 2016 ONCA 656, 132 OR (3d) 241, 352 OAC 290, [2016] OJ No 4615 ................................... 242 671122 Ontario Ltd v Sagaz Industries Canada Inc (1998), 40 OR (3d) 229, 42 CCLT (2d) 50 (Gen Div), aff’d [2001] 2 SCR 983, [2001] SC......
-
Special Topics in Negligence
...his complaint that his estranged wife beat their children with a spatula. 254 In 495793 Ontario Ltd (Central Auto Parts) v Barclay , 2016 ONCA 656, the court held that since police are professionals, expert evidence is required to determine the appropriate standard of care unless their cond......
-
Francis v. Edgar, 2019 ONSC 7454
...Krawchuk, at para. 133. [26] Krawchuk, at para. 135; 495793 Ontario Ltd. v. Barclay, 2016 ONCA 656, 132 O.R. (3d) 241, at para. 57 [27] Meady, at para. 35; Krawchuk, at para. 133. [28] Barclay, at para. 56. [29] Meady, at para. 47. [30] Ibid, at para. 37. [31] Russell v. York Pol......
-
Francis v. Edgar, 2019 ONSC 7454
...Krawchuk, at para. 133. [26] Krawchuk, at para. 135; 495793 Ontario Ltd. v. Barclay, 2016 ONCA 656, 132 O.R. (3d) 241, at para. 57 [27] Meady, at para. 35; Krawchuk, at para. 133. [28] Barclay, at para. 56. [29] Meady, at para. 47. [30] Ibid, at para. 37. [31] Russell v. York Pol......
-
Annett v Enterprise Rent-A-Car Canada Ltd, 2019 ABQB 734
...of care and of whether the standard was met would generally require expert evidence: 495793 Ontario Ltd (Central Auto Parts) v Barclay, 2016 ONCA 656 at paras 53-57, 65, 67. Enterprise’s claim, in CPS’s view, was a type of “negligent investigation” claim, so (by analogy) expert evidence was......
-
R v Shivak, 2020 ABQB 606
...of proof of VIN tampering, was not constitutional: Re Boyle at para 63 (CarswellOnt); 495793 Ontario Ltd (Central Auto Parts) v Barclay, 2016 ONCA 656 at paras 22-25. [243] In Re Boyle, The Court of Appeal upheld the aspect of the presumption declaring that proof of the removal or obliterat......
-
R. v. Gardner and Fraser,
...[2013] S.C.C.A. No. 92; Bergen v. Guliker, 2015 BCCA 283 (police officers); 495793 Ontario Ltd. (Central Auto Parts) v. Barclay, 2016 ONCA 656 (police officers). [70] The same principles seem to apply where the charge is criminal negligence causing death or bodily harm (see for example: R. ......
-
Court Of Appeal Summaries (July 19-23)
...ONCA 425, Payne v. Mak, 2018 ONCA 622, City of Ottawa v. Bentolila, 2006 ONCJ 541, 495793 Ontario Ltd. (Central Auto Parts) v. Barclay, 2016 ONCA 656, Miazga v. Kvello Estate, 2009 SCC 51, Klurfeld v. Nova Quest Logistics Inc., 2016 ONCA 348, Merrifield v. Canada (Attorney General), 2019 ON......
-
Court Of Appeal Summaries (January 27 January 31, 2020)
...Causation, Fontaine v British Columbia (Official Administrator), [1998] 1 SCR 424, 495793 Ontario Ltd. (Central Auto Parts) v. Barclay, 2016 ONCA 656 York Region Standard Condominium Corporation No. 1206 v. 520 Steeles Developments Inc., 2020 ONCA 63 Keywords: Real Property, Condominiums, C......
-
Court Of Appeal Summaries (August 29 September 2, 2016)
...Ltd. v. Elsley, H.L. Staebler Co. v. Allan, Breach of Confidence, Summary Judgment 495793 Ontario Ltd. (Central Auto Parts) v. Barclay, 2016 ONCA 656 Key words: Torts, Negligence, Negligent Police Investigation, Standard of Care, Reasonable and Probable Grounds, Expert Evidence, Damages, No......
-
Appeal Dismissed: There Was No Other Explanation For The Fire, But There Was Also No Expert Evidence
...1 2017 ONSC 7237, affirmed by 2020 ONCA 67 ["MTCC No. 1100"]. 2 MTCC No. 1100, 2017 ONSC 7237, at para. 149. 3 Ibid. at para. 7. 4 2016 ONCA 656 5 Ibid. at para. 57. 6 Id. 7 MTCC No. 1100, 2017 ONSC 7237, at para. 160. 8 MTCC No. 1100, 2020 ONCA 67, at para. 11. 9 Ibid. at paras. 18-19. 10 ......
-
Table of cases
...403 495793 Ontario Ltd (Central Auto Parts) v Barclay, 2016 ONCA 656, 132 OR (3d) 241, 352 OAC 290, [2016] OJ No 4615 ................................... 242 671122 Ontario Ltd v Sagaz Industries Canada Inc (1998), 40 OR (3d) 229, 42 CCLT (2d) 50 (Gen Div), aff’d [2001] 2 SCR 983, [2001] SC......
-
Special Topics in Negligence
...his complaint that his estranged wife beat their children with a spatula. 254 In 495793 Ontario Ltd (Central Auto Parts) v Barclay , 2016 ONCA 656, the court held that since police are professionals, expert evidence is required to determine the appropriate standard of care unless their cond......