Coburn and Watson’s Metropolitan Home v. Home Depot of Canada Inc., 2019 BCCA 308
Jurisdiction | British Columbia |
Judge | Harris,Savage,Hunter |
Citation | 2019 BCCA 308 |
Docket Number | CA45499;CA45513 |
Court | Court of Appeal (British Columbia) |
Date | 30 August 2019 |
-
- This document is available in original version only for vLex customers
View this document and try vLex for 7 days - TRY VLEX
- This document is available in original version only for vLex customers
31 practice notes
-
A Wrench in the Social Justice Toolbox: Assessing the Constitutional Class Action as a Tool for Addressing Racial Discrimination
...Bank of Montreal, 2021 ABCA 40 at para 3. The unsuccessful appeals are Coburn and Watson’s Metropolitan Home v Home Depot of Canada Inc, 2019 BCCA 308, leave to appeal to SCC refused 26 March 2020; Home Depot of Canada Inc c National Bank of Canada Inc, 2019 QCCA 1465, leave to appeal to SC......
-
Revisiting Class Counsel Fee Approvals: Towards Presumptive Validity of Contingency Fee Agreements
...Bank of Montreal, 2021 ABCA 40 at para 3. The unsuccessful appeals are Coburn and Watson’s Metropolitan Home v Home Depot of Canada Inc, 2019 BCCA 308, leave to appeal to SCC refused 26 March 2020; Home Depot of Canada Inc c National Bank of Canada Inc, 2019 QCCA 1465, leave to appeal to SC......
-
The Short End of the Stick: Bolstering Legal Protections for Short Sellers in Ontario’s Secondary Market
...Bank of Montreal, 2021 ABCA 40 at para 3. The unsuccessful appeals are Coburn and Watson’s Metropolitan Home v Home Depot of Canada Inc, 2019 BCCA 308, leave to appeal to SCC refused 26 March 2020; Home Depot of Canada Inc c National Bank of Canada Inc, 2019 QCCA 1465, leave to appeal to SC......
-
Access to Justice: An Objective Or Incidental Effect of Class Actions?
...Bank of Montreal, 2021 ABCA 40 at para 3. The unsuccessful appeals are Coburn and Watson’s Metropolitan Home v Home Depot of Canada Inc, 2019 BCCA 308, leave to appeal to SCC refused 26 March 2020; Home Depot of Canada Inc c National Bank of Canada Inc, 2019 QCCA 1465, leave to appeal to SC......
Request a trial to view additional results
18 cases
-
Strohmaier v. K.S., 2019 BCCA 388
...the hearing of this appeal, reasons for judgment were released in Coburn and Watson’s Metropolitan Home v. Home Depot of Canada Inc., 2019 BCCA 308, where this court held that it does not have jurisdiction to hear an appeal by a class member from an order approving a settlement under s. 6 o......
-
Bancroft-Snell v. Visa Canada Corporation, 2019 ONCA 822
...cited with approval by the Court of Appeal for British Columbia in Coburn and Watson’s Metropolitan Home v. Home Depot of Canada Inc., 2019 BCCA 308 (“Coburn”), released August 30, 2019. That case, a class proceeding related to this, raised precisely the same issue as these motions. The cou......
-
Reddock v. Canada (Attorney General),
...discussed directly or indirectly in: Cobourn and Watson’s Metropolitan Home Ltd. (c.o.b. Metropolitan Home) v. Home Depot of Canada Inc., 2019 BCCA 308; Belley c. TD Auto Finance Services Inc./Services de financement auto TD inc., 2018 QCCA 1727; Trottier c. Canadian Malartic Mine, 2018 QCC......
-
Toronto Standard Condominium Corporation No. 1654 v. Tri-Can Contract Incorporated, 2022 FC 1796
...2643, at paras 31-32; Coburn and Watson’s Metropolitan Home v BMO Financial Group, 2018 BCSC 1183, at paras 32-33 (appeal quashed: 2019 BCCA 308); McKay v Air Canada, 2015 BCSC 1874, at paras 8-9; Gallant v The Roman Catholic Episcopal Corporation of Halifax, 2022 NSSC 347, at para 8......
Request a trial to view additional results
3 firm's commentaries
-
Objectors Unwelcome In The Court Of Appeal: Home Depot Of Canada Inc. v Hello Baby Equipment Inc., 2020 SKCA 7
...276. 2 Bancroft-Snell v. Visa Canada Corporation, 2019 ONCA 822. 3 Coburn and Watson's Metropolitan Home v. Home Depot of Canada Inc., 2019 BCCA 308. 4 Home Depot of Canada Inc. c. National Bank of Canada Inc., 2019 QCCA 1465. Given that the Québec Court of Appeal found that Wal-Mart and Ho......
-
Federal Government Signals Additional Focus On Lowering Credit Card Fees In Fall Economic Statement 2022
...directly. Footnote 1. See Bancroft-Snell v. Visa Canada Corporation, 2019 ONCA 822 (CanLII); Coburn and Watson's Metropolitan Home, 2019 BCCA 308 (CanLII); 9085-4886 Québec Inc. c. Visa Canada Corporation, 2018 QCCS 4872 (CanLII); Macaronies Hair Club and Laser Center Inc v Bank of Montreal......
-
Class Members, No Rights To Appeal Settlement Approval
...fails to pursue an appeal. Justice Strathy rejected this notion, quoting Justice Harris in Coburn and Watson's Metropolitan Home, 2019 BCCA 308: "a judgment on a common issue involves an adjudication by a court of contested issues. It does not capture an order approving a settlement in whic......
9 books & journal articles
-
A Wrench in the Social Justice Toolbox: Assessing the Constitutional Class Action as a Tool for Addressing Racial Discrimination
...Bank of Montreal, 2021 ABCA 40 at para 3. The unsuccessful appeals are Coburn and Watson’s Metropolitan Home v Home Depot of Canada Inc, 2019 BCCA 308, leave to appeal to SCC refused 26 March 2020; Home Depot of Canada Inc c National Bank of Canada Inc, 2019 QCCA 1465, leave to appeal to SC......
-
Revisiting Class Counsel Fee Approvals: Towards Presumptive Validity of Contingency Fee Agreements
...Bank of Montreal, 2021 ABCA 40 at para 3. The unsuccessful appeals are Coburn and Watson’s Metropolitan Home v Home Depot of Canada Inc, 2019 BCCA 308, leave to appeal to SCC refused 26 March 2020; Home Depot of Canada Inc c National Bank of Canada Inc, 2019 QCCA 1465, leave to appeal to SC......
-
The Short End of the Stick: Bolstering Legal Protections for Short Sellers in Ontario’s Secondary Market
...Bank of Montreal, 2021 ABCA 40 at para 3. The unsuccessful appeals are Coburn and Watson’s Metropolitan Home v Home Depot of Canada Inc, 2019 BCCA 308, leave to appeal to SCC refused 26 March 2020; Home Depot of Canada Inc c National Bank of Canada Inc, 2019 QCCA 1465, leave to appeal to SC......
-
Access to Justice: An Objective Or Incidental Effect of Class Actions?
...Bank of Montreal, 2021 ABCA 40 at para 3. The unsuccessful appeals are Coburn and Watson’s Metropolitan Home v Home Depot of Canada Inc, 2019 BCCA 308, leave to appeal to SCC refused 26 March 2020; Home Depot of Canada Inc c National Bank of Canada Inc, 2019 QCCA 1465, leave to appeal to SC......
Request a trial to view additional results