Lefebvre (Bankrupt), Re, 2004 SCC 63
Judge | McLachlin, C.J.C., Major, Bastarache, Binnie and LeBel, JJ. |
Court | Supreme Court (Canada) |
Case Date | October 28, 2004 |
Jurisdiction | Canada (Federal) |
Citations | 2004 SCC 63;(2004), 326 N.R. 353 (SCC) |
Lefebvre (Bankrupt), Re (2004), 326 N.R. 353 (SCC)
MLB headnote and full text
[French language version follows English language version]
[La version française vient à la suite de la version anglaise]
....................
Temp. Cite: [2004] N.R. TBEd. OC.036
Services DaimlerChrysler Canada Inc. (appellant) v. Jean-François Lebel (respondent)
(29770)
GMAC Location Limitée (appellant) v. Raymond Chabot Inc. (respondent)
(29780; 2004 CSC 63; 2004 SCC 63)
Indexed As: Lefebvre (Bankrupt), Re
Supreme Court of Canada
McLachlin, C.J.C., Major, Bastarache, Binnie and LeBel, JJ.
October 28, 2004.
Summary:
In these two appeals, two assignees of long-term vehicle leasing contracts published their ownership rights after the lessees went bankrupt and the trustees took over the vehicles. Each assignee filed a proof of claim with the trustee. They both sought possession of the vehicles of which they were still the owners. Both claims were rejected. Each assignee filed a motion in appeal.
The Quebec Superior Court, in decisions reported at [2001] R.J.Q. 2679 and [2001] J.Q. No. 3446 respectively, dismissed the motions. The assignees appealed. The appeals were heard together.
The Quebec Court of Appeal, Beauregard, J.A., dissenting, in a decision reported at [2003] R.J.Q. 819, dismissed the appeals. The assignees appealed.
The Supreme Court of Canada allowed the appeals.
Bankruptcy - Topic 431
Property of bankrupt - Particular property -Property leased by bankrupt - [See Quebec Nominate Contracts - Topic 1011 ].
Practice - Topic 7029
Costs - Party and party costs - Entitlement to party and party costs - Successful party - Exceptions - Novel or important point - [See Quebec Procedure - Topic 7024 ].
Practice - Topic 7451.1
Costs - Solicitor and client costs - Entitlement to solicitor and client costs - Unsuccessful party - [See Quebec Procedure - Topic 7024 ].
Quebec Nominate Contracts - Topic 1004
Lease - General principles - Effect of lease - [See Quebec Nominate Contracts - Topic 1011 ].
Quebec Nominate Contracts - Topic 1011
Lease - General principles - Publication of rights resulting from lease - The assignees of long-term vehicle leasing contracts published their ownership rights after the lessees went bankrupt and the trustees took over the vehicles - The assignees filed a proof of claim with the trustees, seeking possession of the vehicles - The claims were rejected - The trustees invoked art. 1852 of the Civil Code of Québec respecting publication of rights resulting from a lease - They said that publication was tardy and hence, the assignees' rights could not be set up against them as third persons - The Supreme Court of Canada ruled that the claims should have been allowed - The assignees held ownership rights and not simple claims guaranteed by real securities - Those ownership rights did not result from the lease and had not been transferred to the lessees - The vehicles were never in the lessees' patrimonies and could therefore not be liquidated by the trustees - The Civil Code of Québec did not provide a trustee, in case of failure to publish rights arising out of a lease, with a greater interest than that of the bankrupt so as to allow the trustee to dispose of the subject property - Also, a trustee was not a third person given the dual aspects of his duties, i.e., exercising the bankrupt's rights to hold and dispose of the subject property on the one hand, and being the legal mandatary of the creditors on the other hand.
Quebec Procedure - Topic 7024
Costs - Entitlement - Lawyer-client basis - The Supreme Court of Canada awarded costs on a solicitor-client basis to the unsuccessful respondent where the appellant brought before the court an issue of particular interest that it was more concerned about than the actual outcome of the case and where the participation of the respondent and his counsel was helpful to the analysis of the issues - See paragraph 41.
Cases Noticed:
Ouellet (Bankrupt), Re (2004), 326 N.R. 379 (S.C.C.), refd to. [para. 1].
Giffen (Bankrupt), Re, [1998] 1 S.C.R. 91; 222 N.R. 29; 101 B.C.A.C. 161; 164 W.A.C. 161, refd to. [para. 8].
Massouris (Syndic de), Re, [2002] R.J.Q. 901 (C.A.), refd to. [para. 11].
Mervis (Syndic de), Re, [2002] R.J.Q. 2268, refd to. [para. 11].
Civano Construction Inc. v. Crédit M.-G. Inc., [1962] C.S. 45 (Que.), refd to. [para. 34].
Kowalski v. Trust Général du Canada, [1976] C.A. 93 (Que.), refd to. [para. 34].
Poliquin v. Banque de Montreal, [1998] R.L. 560 (Que. C.A.), refd to. [para. 34].
Mercure v. Marquette (A.) & Fils Inc., [1977] 1 S.C.R. 54; 10 N.R. 234, refd to. [para. 36].
Flintoft v. Royal Bank of Canada, [1964] S.C.R. 631, refd to. [para. 37].
Statutes Noticed:
Civil Code of Québec, S.Q. 1991, c. 64, art. 1852, art. 2941 [para. 15].
Authors and Works Noticed:
Auger, Jacques, and Bohémier, Albert, Le statut du syndic (2003), 37 R.J.T. 59, pp. 67 and 102 to 106 [para. 34].
Cantin Cumyn, Madeleine, Traité de droit civil: L'administration du bien d'autrui, 2000, pp. 110 to 112 [para. 35].
Lafond Pierre-Claude, Précis de droit des biens, 2e éd., 1999, p. 192 [para. 21].
Lamontagne, Denys-Claude, avec la collaboration de Pierre Duchaine, La publicité des droits, 3e éd., 2001, pp. 31, 32, 301 [para. 22].
Macdonald, Roderick A., Faut-il s'assurer qu'on appelle un chat un chat? Observations sur la méthodologie législative à travers l'énumération limitative des sûretés, "la présomption d'hypothèque" et "le principe de l'essence de l'opération", dans Mélanges Germain Brière, 1993, p. 527 [para. 20].
Payette, Louis, Les sûretés réelles dans le Code civil du Québec, 2e éd., 2001, pp. 2, 3, 59, 60 to 64 [para. 20].
Québec, Ministère de la Justice, Commentaires du ministre de la Justice: Le Code civil du Québec, t. II., 1993, p. 1654 [para. 20].
Québec, Office de révision du Code civil. Rapport sur le Code civil du Québec, vol. II., 1977, t. 1, pp. 431-435 [para. 20].
Counsel:
Yves Lacroix and Gary Makila, for the appellant, Services DaimlerChrysler Canada Inc.;
Hugues La Rue, for the appellant GMAC Location Ltée;
Martin P. Jutras, for the respondent Jean-François Lebel.
No one appeared for the respondent Raymond Chabot Inc.
Solicitors of Record:
Fasken Martineau DuMoulin, Québec, Quebec, for the appellant, Services DaimlerChrysler Inc.;
Pothier Delisle, Sainte-Foy, Québec, for the appellant, GMAC Location Ltée;
Martin P. Jutras, Westmount, Québec, for the respondent Jean-François Lebel.
These appeals were heard on April 20, 2004, by McLachlin, C.J.C., Major, Bastarache, Binnie and LeBel, JJ., of the Supreme Court of Canada.
The judgment of the Supreme Court was delivered in both official languages on October 28, 2004, by LeBel, J.
To continue reading
Request your trial-
Association de m_diation familiale du Qu_bec v. Bouvier,
...v. Société Radio‑Canada, 2016 QCCA 1715; Ouellet (Trustee of), 2004 SCC 64, [2004] 3 S.C.R. 348; Lefebvre (Trustee of), 2004 SCC 63, [2004] 3 S.C.R. 326; CIBC Mortgage Corp. v. Vasquez, 2002 SCC 60, [2002] 3 S.C.R. 168; Roberge v. Bolduc, [1991] 1 S.C.R. 374. Statutes and R......
-
Chandos Construction Ltd. v. Deloitte Restructuring Inc., 2020 SCC 25
...v. McKinnon (1922), 64 S.C.R. 396; Zimmerman v. Letkeman, [1978] 1 S.C.R. 1097; Giffen (Re), [1998] 1 S.C.R. 91; Lefebvre (Trustee of), 2004 SCC 63, [2004] 3 S.C.R. 326; Flintoft v. Royal Bank of Canada, [1964] S.C.R. 631; Saulnier v. Royal Bank of Canada, 2008 SCC 58, [2008] 3 S.C.R. 166; ......
-
Table of cases
...2 QB 318 (CA) .................................................................... 135 Lefebvre (Trustee of); Tremblay (Trustee of), 2004 SCC 63 ................................................................... 112, 118–19, 574, 603 Legaarden v Abernethy Credit Union Ltd (1991), 3 PPSAC (......
-
Table of Cases
...2 QB 318 (CA) .................................................................... 128 Lefebvre (Trustee of); Tremblay (Trustee of), 2004 SCC 63 ..............112, 519, 546 Legaarden v Abernethy Credit Union Ltd (1991), 3 PPSAC (2d) 292, [1991] SJ No 651 (QB) .....................................
-
Sharp v Autorité des marchés financiers,
...SCC 57, [2019] 4 S.C.R. 138; Peoples Department Stores Inc. (Trustee of) v. Wise, 2004 SCC 68, [2004] 3 S.C.R. 461; Lefebvre (Trustee of), 2004 SCC 63, [2004] 3 S.C.R. 326; Quebec (Commission des normes du travail) v. Asphalte Desjardins inc., 2014 SCC 51, [2014] 2 S.C.R. 514; Béliveau......
-
Sharp v. Autorité des marchés financiers, 2023 SCC 29
...SCC 57, [2019] 4 S.C.R. 138; Peoples Department Stores Inc. (Trustee of) v. Wise, 2004 SCC 68, [2004] 3 S.C.R. 461; Lefebvre (Trustee of), 2004 SCC 63, [2004] 3 S.C.R. 326; Quebec (Commission des normes du travail) v. Asphalte Desjardins inc., 2014 SCC 51, [2014] 2 S.C.R. 514; Béliveau......
-
Association de m_diation familiale du Qu_bec v. Bouvier,
...v. Société Radio‑Canada, 2016 QCCA 1715; Ouellet (Trustee of), 2004 SCC 64, [2004] 3 S.C.R. 348; Lefebvre (Trustee of), 2004 SCC 63, [2004] 3 S.C.R. 326; CIBC Mortgage Corp. v. Vasquez, 2002 SCC 60, [2002] 3 S.C.R. 168; Roberge v. Bolduc, [1991] 1 S.C.R. 374. Statutes and R......
-
Chandos Construction Ltd. v. Deloitte Restructuring Inc., 2020 SCC 25
...v. McKinnon (1922), 64 S.C.R. 396; Zimmerman v. Letkeman, [1978] 1 S.C.R. 1097; Giffen (Re), [1998] 1 S.C.R. 91; Lefebvre (Trustee of), 2004 SCC 63, [2004] 3 S.C.R. 326; Flintoft v. Royal Bank of Canada, [1964] S.C.R. 631; Saulnier v. Royal Bank of Canada, 2008 SCC 58, [2008] 3 S.C.R. 166; ......
-
Two Recent Ontario Cases Act As A Reminder And Reconfirmation
...innocent purchaser of an unregistered leased good may claim the property against a lessor. In Lefebvre (Trustee of); Tremblay (Trustee of) 2004 SCC 63, the Supreme Court of Canada stated a trustee in bankruptcy is not a third party, rather the trustee steps into the role of the lessee and t......
-
Table of cases
...2 QB 318 (CA) .................................................................... 135 Lefebvre (Trustee of); Tremblay (Trustee of), 2004 SCC 63 ................................................................... 112, 118–19, 574, 603 Legaarden v Abernethy Credit Union Ltd (1991), 3 PPSAC (......
-
Table of Cases
...2 QB 318 (CA) .................................................................... 128 Lefebvre (Trustee of); Tremblay (Trustee of), 2004 SCC 63 ..............112, 519, 546 Legaarden v Abernethy Credit Union Ltd (1991), 3 PPSAC (2d) 292, [1991] SJ No 651 (QB) .....................................
-
Bijuralism and Bilingualism in Canada: The Role of the Federal Courts
...]. 186 Allard & Jacquier, above note 89 at 26; Grenon, above note 183 at para 47. See also Lefebvre (Trustee of); Tremblay (Trustee of) , 2004 SCC 63. 187 DIMS , above note 185 at para 64. 188 Grenon, above note 183 at para 48. 189 Ibid at para 49 [our translation]. 190 Re Canada 3000 Inc; ......
-
Introduction and General Considerations
...sur le code civil du Québec” vol. II (Quebec: Éditeur oiciel, 1978) at 1 and 431. 582 Lefebvre (Trustee of); Tremblay (Trustee of) , 2004 SCC 63 at para 20, LeBel J [ Lefebvre (Trustee of) ]. 583 CCQ art 1750(1). 584 CCQ art 1750(2). 585 Ibid . See art 15.01 of the Regulation respecting the......