Reid Crowther & Partners Ltd. v. Simcoe & Erie General Insurance Co., (1993) 147 N.R. 44 (SCC)
Judge | La Forest, Sopinka, Gonthier, Cory and McLachlin, JJ.A. |
Court | Supreme Court (Canada) |
Case Date | January 21, 1993 |
Jurisdiction | Canada (Federal) |
Citations | (1993), 147 N.R. 44 (SCC);1993 CanLII 150 (SCC);147 NR 44;[1993] 2 WWR 433;99 DLR (4th) 741;[1993] CarswellMan 96;83 Man R (2d) 81;46 MVR (2d) 26;[1993] ILR 1;JE 93-230;AZ-93111005;36 WAC 81;13 CCLI (2d) 161;[1993] ACS no 10;[1993] SCJ No 10 (QL);[1993] 1 SCR 252;6 CLR (2d) 161 |
Reid Crowther v. Simcoe & Erie (1993), 147 N.R. 44 (SCC)
MLB headnote and full text
[French language version follows English language version]
[La version française vient à la suite de la version anglaise]
....................
Simcoe & Erie General Insurance Company (appellant) v. Reid Crowther & Partners Limited (respondent)
(22372)
Indexed As: Reid Crowther & Partners Ltd. v. Simcoe & Erie General Insurance Co.
Supreme Court of Canada
La Forest, Sopinka, Gonthier, Cory
and McLachlin, JJ.A.
January 21, 1993.
Summary:
An engineering firm negligently supervised installation of water and sewer lines in a municipality and was held liable for remedial work. The firm claimed the damages from its insurer under a "claims- made" policy. One claim was settled, but a second claim was made for further damage discovered just before the policy expired. The insurer denied liability on the ground that the claim was not made within the policy period.
The Manitoba Court of Queen's Bench dismissed the firm's action in a judgment reported [1990] I.L.R. 1-2642; 66 Man.R.(2d) 142; 45 C.C.L.I. 172. The firm appealed.
The Manitoba Court of Appeal allowed the appeal in a judgment reported [1990] I.L.R. 1-2703; 70 Man.R.(2d) 36; 77 D.L.R.(4th) 243; 47 C.C.L.I. 309 (supplementary judgment on interest reported 73 Man.R.(2d) 128). The insurer appealed.
The Supreme Court of Canada dismissed the appeal.
Insurance - Topic 7628
Professional liability insurance - Scope of coverage - Policy period - Claims made - Meaning of - The Supreme Court of Canada discussed and distinguished claims-made or discovery policies and occurrence policies and their hybrids, including the origins and purpose of claims-made policies and insurers' practices regarding them - See paragraphs 9 to 27.
Insurance - Topic 7628
Professional liability insurance - Scope of coverage - Policy period - Claims made - Meaning of - An engineering consulting firm negligently supervised installation of a municipal water and sewerage system - The firm was insured under a "claims-made" policy, providing indemnity when a claim was made against the insured within the policy period, regardless of when the loss occurred or was discovered - The insurer settled a claim during the policy period - Then, just before the policy expired the municipality showed the firm additional damage, which the firm treated as a demand for compensation and so informed the insurer just after the policy expired - The Supreme Court of Canada held that the additional damage was covered as part of the original claim - See paragraphs 1 to 40.
Insurance - Topic 7628
Professional liability insurance - Scope of coverage - Policy period - Claims made - Meaning of - An engineering consulting firm negligently supervised installation of a municipal water and sewerage system - The firm was insured under a "claims-made" policy, providing indemnity when a claim was made against the insured within the policy period, regardless of when the loss occurred or was discovered - The insurer settled a claim during the policy period - Then, just before the policy expired the municipality showed the firm additional damage, which the firm treated as a demand for compensation and so informed the insurer just after the policy expired - The Supreme Court of Canada held that the municipality's showing of the additional damage to the firm constituted a claim within the policy period - See paragraphs 41 to 55.
Cases Noticed:
Brissette Estate v. Westbury Life Insurance Co., [1992] 3 S.C.R. 87; 142 N.R. 104; 58 O.A.C. 10, consd. [para. 32].
Wigle v. Allstate Insurance Co. of Canada (1984), 49 O.R.(2d) 101, leave to appeal refused [1985] 1 S.C.R. v; 59 N.R. 73, consd. [para. 38].
Continental Casualty Co. v. Enco Associates Inc., 238 N.W. 2d 198, consd. [para. 42].
Williamson & Vollmer Engineering Inc. v. Sequoia Insurance Co., 134 Cal. Rptr. 427, consd. [para. 42].
San Pedro Properties Inc. v. Sayre & Toso Inc., 21 Cal. Rptr. 844, consd. [para. 42].
Hoyt v. St Paul Fire and Marine Insurance Co., 607 F.2d 864, consd. [para. 42].
Phoenix Insurance Co. v. Sukut Construction Co., 186 Cal. Rptr. 513, consd. [para. 42].
Mt. Hawley Insurance Co. v. Federal Savings & Loan Insurance Corp., 695 F.Supp. 469, consd. [para. 42].
Jensen v. Snellings, 841 F.2d 600, consd. [para. 42].
Safeco Title Insurance Co. v. Gannon, 774 P.2d 30, consd. [para. 42].
Stevenson v. Simcoe & Erie General Insurance Co., [1981] I.L.R. 1-1434, dist. [paras 42, 53].
St. Paul Fire and Marine Insurance Co. v. Guardian Insurance Co. of Canada (1983), 2 O.A.C. 109; 2 C.C.L.I. 275, dist. [paras. 42, 50, 54].
Peacock v. Roberts (1985), 15 C.C.L.I. 36, affd. (1990) 42 C.C.L.I. 196, consd. [paras. 42, 50].
McNish & McNish v. American Home Assurance Co. (1989), 39 C.C.L.I. 200, affd. 5 C.C.L.I.(2d) 222, consd. [para. 42].
Defrancesco v. Stivala, [1989] I.L.R. 1-2524, revd. [1992] O.J. No. 2116, consd. [paras. 42, 53, 54].
J.G. Link & Co. v. Continental Casualty Co. (1972), 470 F.2d 1133; 414 U.S. 829, consd. [para. 46].
Continental Casualty Co. v. Robert McLellan & Co., [1973] 5 W.W.R. 475, consd. [para. 48].
Authors and Works Noticed:
Brown, Craig and Julio Menezes, Insurance Law in Canada (2nd Ed. 1991), pp. 123-131 [para. 32].
Davis, Thomas R.M., The New IBC Standard Form Commercial General (Claims-Made) Liability Policy (1987), 5 Can. J. Ins. L. 77, 78 [para. 25].
Dumont, Jeanine, What Every Professional Should Know Before Buying Claims-Made Liability Insurance (1985), 35 Fed. Ins. Couns. Q. 363 [para. 42].
Hilliker, Gordon, Liability Insurance Law in Canada (1991), pp. 136-137 [para. 42].
Long, Rowland H., The Law of Liability Insurance (1992), vol. 2, pp. 12C-54 [para. 42].
Parker, John K., The Untimely Demise of the "Claims-Made" Insurance Form? A Critique of Stine V. Continental Casualty Company, [1983] Det. Coll. L.R. 25, 27 [para. 11].
Pierce, Lee Roy, Jr., Professional Liability Insurance: The Claims-Made and Reported Trap (1991), 19 W. St. U.L. Rev. 165, 171 [para. 24].
Counsel:
David I. Marr, for the appellant;
Leonard M. French and Dennis Ringstrom, for the respondent.
Solicitors of Record:
Campbell, Marr, Winnipeg, Manitoba, for the appellant;
Fillmore and Riley, Winnipeg, Manitoba, for the respondent.
This case was heard on October 13, 1992, at Ottawa, Ontario, before La Forest, Sopinka, Gonthier, Cory and McLachlin, JJ.A., of the Supreme Court of Canada.
On January 21, 1993, McLachlin, J., delivered the following judgment for the Court in both official languages:
To continue reading
Request your trial-
Engle Estate v. Aviva Insurance Co. of Canada, 2010 ABCA 18
...58 O.A.C. 10; 96 D.L.R.(4th) 609, refd to. [para. 16]. Reid Crowther & Partners Ltd. v. Simcoe & Erie General Insurance Co., [1993] 1 S.C.R. 252; 147 N.R. 44; 83 Man.R.(2d) 81; 36 W.A.C. 81; 99 D.L.R.(4th) 741, refd to. [para. Authors and Works Noticed: Brown, Craig, and Donnelly, T......
-
Scalera v. Lloyd's of London, (2000) 135 B.C.A.C. 161 (SCC)
...O.A.C. 161; 49 O.R.(2d) 101 (C.A.), refd to. [para. 70]. Reid Crowther & Partners Ltd. v. Simcoe & Erie General Insurance Co., [1993] 1 S.C.R. 252; 147 N.R. 44; 83 Man.R.(2d) 81; 36 W.A.C. 81, refd to. [para. Indemnity Insurance Co. v. Excel Cleaning Service, [1954] S.C.R. 169, refd......
-
Dunn v. Chubb Insurance Company of Canada,
...114 O.A.C. 357 (C.A.), refd to. [para. 34, footnote 4]. Reid Crowther & Partners Ltd. v. Simcoe & Erie General Insurance Co., [1993] 1 S.C.R. 252; 147 N.R. 44; 83 Man.R.(2d) 81; 36 W.A.C. 81, refd to. [para. Canadian National Railway Co. et al. v. Royal & Sun Alliance Insurance ......
-
Polowin Real Estate v. Dominion of Can., (2005) 199 O.A.C. 266 (CA)
...87; 142 N.R. 104; 58 O.A.C. 10, refd to. [para. 74]. Reid Crowther & Partners Ltd. v. Simcoe & Erie General Insurance Co., [1993] 1 S.C.R. 252; 147 N.R. 44; 83 Man.R.(2d) 81; 36 W.A.C. 81, refd to. [para. 79]. Chilton v. Co-Operators General Insurance Co. (1997), 97 O.A.C. 369; 32 O......
-
Engle Estate v. Aviva Insurance Co. of Canada, 2010 ABCA 18
...58 O.A.C. 10; 96 D.L.R.(4th) 609, refd to. [para. 16]. Reid Crowther & Partners Ltd. v. Simcoe & Erie General Insurance Co., [1993] 1 S.C.R. 252; 147 N.R. 44; 83 Man.R.(2d) 81; 36 W.A.C. 81; 99 D.L.R.(4th) 741, refd to. [para. Authors and Works Noticed: Brown, Craig, and Donnelly, T......
-
Scalera v. Lloyd's of London, (2000) 135 B.C.A.C. 161 (SCC)
...O.A.C. 161; 49 O.R.(2d) 101 (C.A.), refd to. [para. 70]. Reid Crowther & Partners Ltd. v. Simcoe & Erie General Insurance Co., [1993] 1 S.C.R. 252; 147 N.R. 44; 83 Man.R.(2d) 81; 36 W.A.C. 81, refd to. [para. Indemnity Insurance Co. v. Excel Cleaning Service, [1954] S.C.R. 169, refd......
-
Dunn v. Chubb Insurance Company of Canada,
...114 O.A.C. 357 (C.A.), refd to. [para. 34, footnote 4]. Reid Crowther & Partners Ltd. v. Simcoe & Erie General Insurance Co., [1993] 1 S.C.R. 252; 147 N.R. 44; 83 Man.R.(2d) 81; 36 W.A.C. 81, refd to. [para. Canadian National Railway Co. et al. v. Royal & Sun Alliance Insurance ......
-
Polowin Real Estate v. Dominion of Can., (2005) 199 O.A.C. 266 (CA)
...87; 142 N.R. 104; 58 O.A.C. 10, refd to. [para. 74]. Reid Crowther & Partners Ltd. v. Simcoe & Erie General Insurance Co., [1993] 1 S.C.R. 252; 147 N.R. 44; 83 Man.R.(2d) 81; 36 W.A.C. 81, refd to. [para. 79]. Chilton v. Co-Operators General Insurance Co. (1997), 97 O.A.C. 369; 32 O......
-
Court Of Appeal Summaries (April 18 - 22, 2022)
...37, Consolidated-Bathurst v. Mutual Boiler, [1980] 1 S.C.R. 888, Reid Crowther & Partners Ltd. v. Simcoe & Erie General Insurance Co., [1993] 1 S.C.R. 252, Progressive Homes Ltd. v. Lombard General Insurance Co. of Canada, 2010 SCC 33, [2010] 2 S.C.R. 245, Surespan Structures Ltd. v. Lloyds......
-
Hail To The Chief: McLachlin C.J.C. Becomes Canadas Longest-Serving Chief Justice
...v. American Home Assurance Co., [1990] 1 S.C.R. 801, Reid Crowther & Partners Ltd. v. Simcoe & Erie General Insurance Co., [1993] 1 S.C.R. 252, Continental Bank Leasing Corp. v. Canada, [1998] 2 S.C.R. 298, Fidler v. Sun Life Assurance Co. Of Canada, [2006] 2 S.C.R. 3, Jedfro Invest......
-
Unrealistic Coverage: Insurer Tripped Up By Loose Policy Language Case Study: Surespan Structures Ltd. V Lloyds Underwriters
...perhaps in the Scalera decision '?" see fns. 18-19 above. 23 As in Reid Crowther & Partners Ltd. v Simcoe & Erie General Insurance Co. [1993] 1 S.C.R. 252 at para. 24 Guarantee Co. of North America v Gordon Capital Corp. [1999] 3 S.C.R. 423 at para. 64, where the issue was raised in the con......
-
Ernst & Young v. Chartis: Claim For An Insurers Breach Of Duty Of Good Faith Does Not Form Part Of 'Proceeds From Insurance Coverage'
...66 Alta LR (4th) 231, leave to appeal to SCC refused, [2007] SCCA No 9. 4 2010 ABQB 26, 479 AR 202. 5 See the exclusions at para 22. 6 [1993] 1 SCR 252 at p 269 per McLachlin J. 7 At paras 57-63. 8 At paras 69-87. 9 At paras 73-75. 10 See Whiten v. Pilot Insurance Co. (1999), 42 OR (3d) 641......
-
Table of cases
...69–70, 78 Reid Crowther & Partners Ltd v Simcoe & Erie General Insurance Co, [1993] 1 SCR 252, 13 CCLI (2d) 161, [1993] SCJ No 10 ..............283, 286, 288, 292, 319, 320 410 Remington Development Corp v Enmax Power Corp, 2012 ABCA 196 ............581 INSUR ANCE LAW 642 Renshaw v Phoenix ......
-
Table of cases
...v. Telegram Publishing Co., (1961) 28 D.L.R. (2d) 6 (Ont. H.C.J.) 733 Reid Crowther & Partners Ltd. v. Simcoe & Erie General Ins. Co., [1993] 1 S.C.R. 252 930 Reidy v. Leader Star News Services, 2001 SKQB 338, [2001] S.J. No. 444 96 Reilanderv. Bengert (1908), 7 W.L.R. 891 (Sask. C.A.) 745 ......
-
The Settlement Process
...note 276 at paras 79–81; Monenco , above note 276 at para 35. 281 Reid Crowther & Partners Ltd v Simcoe & Erie General Insurance Co, [1993] 1 SCR 252 at 269, McLachlin J. See also Scalera , above note 276 at para 70; Jesuit The Settlement Process 411 identical phrase may be interpreted diff......
-
Table of cases
...Reid Crowther & Partners Ltd. v. Simcoe & Erie General Insurance Co., [1993] 1 S.C.R. 252, 99 D.L.R. (4th) 741 ..................................................191 Renshaw v. Pheonix Insurance Co., [1943] O.R. 223, [1943] 2 D.L.R. 76 (C.A.) .......................................................