Routkovskaia v. Gibson, 2020 BCCA 84
| Jurisdiction | British Columbia |
| Judge | The Honourable Madam Justice Newbury,The Honourable Mr. Justice Goepel,The Honourable Mr. Justice Butler |
| Citation | 2020 BCCA 84 |
| Docket Number | CA46228 |
| Court | Court of Appeal (British Columbia) |
| Date | 09 March 2020 |
-
- This document is available in original version only for vLex customers
View this document and try vLex for 7 days - TRY VLEX
- This document is available in original version only for vLex customers
3 practice notes
-
AR v JU,
...2020 NSCA 1 at paras 6-24, 384 CCC (3d) 461; R v Jimenez, 2020 YKCA 5, at paras 34-36, [2020] YJ No 52 (QL); Routkovskaia v Gibson, 2020 BCCA 84 at para [60] We do not doubt that Rooke ACJ’s reasons were arrived at in a judicial manner, particularly given the presumption of judicial integri......
-
M. McIsaac Family Holdings Ltd. v. Tolam Holdings Ltd.,
...the substance of the judge’s reasoning after giving oral reasons could be seen as attempting to defeat an appeal: Routkovskaia v. Gibson, 2020 BCCA 84 at paras. 12–13; Alers‑Hankey v. Solomon et al, 2000 BCCA 196 at paras. 15–17; Ewert v. Canada (Attorney General), 2017 BCSC 279 at paras. 3......
-
M. McIsaac Family Holdings Ltd. v. Tolam Holdings Ltd., 2020 BCCA 167
...judge’s reasons. Thus, a litigant is not entitled as of right to a transcript of the unedited oral reasons: Routkovskaia v. Gibson, 2020 BCCA 84 at para. 13. As Justice Goepel wrote in Routkovskaia, in those cases where edits in reasons may give rise to a ground of appeal, a par......
3 cases
-
AR v JU,
...2020 NSCA 1 at paras 6-24, 384 CCC (3d) 461; R v Jimenez, 2020 YKCA 5, at paras 34-36, [2020] YJ No 52 (QL); Routkovskaia v Gibson, 2020 BCCA 84 at para [60] We do not doubt that Rooke ACJ’s reasons were arrived at in a judicial manner, particularly given the presumption of judicial integri......
-
M. McIsaac Family Holdings Ltd. v. Tolam Holdings Ltd.,
...the substance of the judge’s reasoning after giving oral reasons could be seen as attempting to defeat an appeal: Routkovskaia v. Gibson, 2020 BCCA 84 at paras. 12–13; Alers‑Hankey v. Solomon et al, 2000 BCCA 196 at paras. 15–17; Ewert v. Canada (Attorney General), 2017 BCSC 279 at paras. 3......
-
M. McIsaac Family Holdings Ltd. v. Tolam Holdings Ltd., 2020 BCCA 167
...judge’s reasons. Thus, a litigant is not entitled as of right to a transcript of the unedited oral reasons: Routkovskaia v. Gibson, 2020 BCCA 84 at para. 13. As Justice Goepel wrote in Routkovskaia, in those cases where edits in reasons may give rise to a ground of appeal, a par......