Table of Cases

• Author: Ari Kaplan/Mitch Frazer
• Pages: 619-651

619

TABLE OF CASES

1346687 Ontar io Inc v Canada (Minister of Nation al Revenue - MNR),

2007 FCA 262, leave to appeal to SCC ref used, [2007] SCCA No 481 ...... 104

1398874 Ontario Inc v Canad a (Minister of National Revenue - MNR),

2010 FCA 14 ................................................................................................. 104

700 King Street (1997) Ltd (Trustee in Bank ruptcy) v Acro Capital Inc

(2004), 70 OR (3d) 191, 49 CBR (4th) 309, [2004] OJ No 1038 (SCJ) ........ 345

A&P Canada Inc v Ont ario (Superintendent of Financial S ervices) and

CAW Local 414 (2007 & 2008), FST Decision No P0277-2006-1

(Ont FST) ......................................................................................................176

AbitibiBowater Inc (Ar rangement relatif à), 2009 QCCS 2028 ......................... 407

Abraham v Ca nadian Admiral Cor p (Receiver and Ma nager of) (1998),

39 OR (3d) 176, 19 CCPB 1, [1998] OJ No 1298 (CA), leave to appeal

to SCC refused, [1998] SCCA No 276 ...................................................21, 4 02

Acreman v Memori al University of Newfoundland, 2010 NLTD 4,

a’d 2011 NLCA 55 .....................................................................................32 6

Adams v Norcen Energ y Resources Ltd, 1998 ABQB 913 .................................. 358

Adams v Norcen Energ y Resources Ltd, 1999 ABQB 840 ................................. 373

Aegon Canada Inc v ING Ca nada Inc (2003), 34 CCPB 1,

48 ETR (2d) 170, [2003] OJ No 448 (SCJ), a’d (2003),

179 OAC 196, 38 CCPB 1, [2003] OJ No 4755 (CA), leave to

appeal to SCC refus ed, [2004] SCCA No 50.................................. 18, 410, 414

Aegon Canada Inc v ING Ca nada Inc (2003), 179 OAC 196, 38 CCPB 1,

[2003] OJ No 4755 (CA), a’g [2003] OTC 48, 36 CCPB 161,

[2003] OJ No 1239 (SCJ) ........................................................17, 476, 502, 504

Air Canad a Pilots Assn v Kelly, 2012 FCA 209 .................................................. 275

PENSIO N LAW620

Alberta (Gami ng and Liquor Commission) v Davies,

2003 ABQB 789 ...................................................... 114, 115, 119, 606, 611, 617

Allen et al v The Superi ntendent of Pensions, Price Waterhouse,

Administ rator of the MCC Plan and Massey Ferguson

Industr ies Limited (18 June 1992) (1992) 3(2) Pension

Bulletin 36 (PCO) ....................................................................481, 506, 507, 556

Allegheny Inter national Canada Ltd v Ada ms, [1992] OJ No 2148

(Ge n Div) .........................................................11, 149, 155, 577, 578, 610, 616

Allison v Noran da Inc, 2001 NBCA 67 .............................................................. 267

Alyea v Alyea, 2016 ONSC 4878 ......................................................................... 106

AM Internat ional Inc Employee Pension Plans (Trustee of), [1982]

OJ No 1090 (HCJ) .........................................................................575, 598, 616

Amalgamat ed Transit Union, Lo cal 1182 (Re), [2003]

NBLEBD No 39 ............................................................................................ 2 02

Amalgamat ed Transit Union, Lo cal 1290 v New Brunswick

(Superintendent of Pensions), [2004] NBLEBD No 2 ................................. 202

Amherst Crane R entals Ltd v Perring (2004), 241 DLR (4th) 176,

41 CCPB 1, [2004] OJ No 2558 (CA).....................................................249 –50

Amoco Canad a Petroleum Co v Alber ta (Superintendent of Pensions)

(1992), 130 AR 360, [1992] AJ No 543 (QB) ........................................598, 616

Anova Inc Employee Retire ment Pension Plan (Adm inistrator of) v

Manufacturer s Life Insurance Co (1994), 121 DLR (4th) 162, 1

1 CCPB 67, [1994] OJ No 2938 (Gen Div) .................... 149, 155, 156, 338, 347

Archibald et al v O ntario (CEO of FSRA),

2019 ONFST 16 ......................................................151, 154, 555, 557, 559, 560

Arrangement rel atif à Bloom Lake, 2017 QCCS 4057 ................................399, 554

Arrowhead Meta ls Ltd v Royal Trust Company (26 March 1992)

(1992) 3(1) Pension Bulletin 19 (PCO) ........................120, 154, 518, 606, 616

Askin v Onta rio Hospital Associat ion (1991), 2 OR (3d) 641,

46 OAC 278, [1991] OJ No 211 (CA) ....................................................410 , 413

Assoc provi nciale des retraités d’Hydro -Québec c Hydro-Québec,

2005 QCCA 304 .................................................................................. 466 , 472

Attorney General of Nova S cotia v Attorney General of Cana da (1950),

[1951] SCR 31, [1950] 4 DLR 369, [1950] SCJ No 32 .................................... 22

Ault v Canada (Attorne y General), 2011 ONCA 147, leave to appeal

to SCC refused, [2011] SCCA No 206 ............................326, 327, 341–42, 538

Austin v Bell C anada, 2018 ONSC 4018, rev’d on other grounds,

2020 ONCA 142 ................................................................................... 130, 257

Austin v Bell C anada, 2019 ONSC 4757 ............................................................. 155

Baker v Canad a (Minister of Citizenship a nd Immigration), [1999]

2 SCR 817, 174 DLR (4th) 193, 1999 CanLII 699 .......................................... 34

Bank of Nova Scoti a v Thibault, 200 4 SCC 29 ...................................................248

Bannerm an v Wilkie East Corp, [1995] OJ No 3084 (Gen Div) .........................191

Barot v Ontar io (Superintendent Fin ancial Services),2015 ONFST 14 ....248, 250

Barot v Ontar io (Superintendent Fin ancial Services), 2015 ONFST 21 .............191

Table of Cases 621

Bathgate v National Ho ckey League Pension Society (1992),

11 OR (3d) 449, 98 DLR (4th) 326, [1992] OJ No 2168 (Gen Div),

a’d (1994), 16 OR (3d) 761, 110 DLR (4th) 609, [1994] OJ No 265 (CA),

leave to appeal to SCC ref used (1994), 4 ETR (2d) 36 ...........8, 12, 13, 14, 18,

157, 327, 331, 338, 348, 349, 466, 471, 472, 505, 598, 606, 607, 614

Baxter v Ont ario (Superintendent of Financial Se rvices)

(2002), 33 CCPB 43, 2002 CarswellOnt 7911 (FST) ....................................174

Baxter v Ont ario (Superintendent of Financial Se rvices) (2004),

192 OAC 293, 43 CCPB 1, [2004] OJ No 4909 (Div Ct) ............. 17, 30, 68, 92,

144, 146, 162, 164, 490, 498, 501, 504, 505, 515, 601, 602, 604, 617

BCE Inc v Ontario (Super intendent Financial Serv ices),

2012 ONFST 25 .....................................................169, 176, 179, 180, 181, 182

Beaudry v BC Hyd ro and Power Authority, [1992] BCJ No 67 (SC) .................. 342

Beauregard v Ca nada, [1986] 2 SCR 56, 30 DLR (4th) 481,

1986 CanLII 24 ........................................................................................ 12, 23

Beccarea v C anadian National Rai lway Company, 2018 ONSC 630 .................159

Beesley v Intern ational Paper Co, 2008 WL 4450319 (SD Ill) .......................... 373

Bégin v Rich mond School District No 38, 2007 BCHRT 60 .............................. 277

Bell Canad a v Quebec, [1988] 1 SCR 749, 51 DLR (4th) 161,

1988 CanLII 8 ................................................................................................ 20

Bell v Ontar io Power Generation Inc, 2 017 ONCA 587 .............................158, 283

Bellai v IWA – Forest Indust ry Pension Plan (Trustees of),

2003 BCSC 1077 .......................................................................................... 219

Belton v Belton, 2 010 ONSC 2400 ...................................................................... 309

Bennett v Bennett (200 4), 9 RFL (6th) 242, [2004] OJ No 5808

(Div Ct) ........................................................................................................ 308

Bennett v Briti sh Columbia, 2012 BCCA 115 .................................................... 603

Bennett v Sear s Canada Inc, 2011 ONSC 6900 ..................................................3 45

Bentall Cor p v Canada Trust Co, 1996 CanLII 8640 (BC SC) .......................... 374

Besse v Dr A S Machner Inc, 2009 BCSC 1316 ..............................................216 –17

Best v Best, [1999] 2 SCR 868, 174 DLR (4th) 235, [1999]

SCJ No 40 ...................................................................................... 60, 282, 299

BF Goodrich Tire M anufacturing v USWA, Local 677, [2007]

OLAA No 430, 2007 Carswe llOnt 8022 (Arbitration Board) ..................... 273

BICC Cables Canada Inc v O ntario (Superintendent of Financia l

Service s) (2000), 26 CCPB 179 (Ont FST) ..................................................152

BICC Cables Canada Inc v O ntario (Superintendent of Financia l

Service s) (2001), 147 OAC 252, 27 CCPB 201, [2001] OJ No 1856

(Div Ct) .......................................................................... 11, 125, 258, 259, 544

Bielanski v Biel anski, [2005] OJ No 2171 (SCJ) .................................................309

Bigsby v Albert a (Pensions Adm inistration), 2005 ABCA 52 .............. 29, 273, 280

Billes, (1983), 42 OR (2d) 110, 148 DLR (3d) 512, [1983]

OJ No 3057 (HCJ) ........................................................................................348

Bisaillon v Concord ia University, 2006 SCC 19 ...........................74, 153, 465, 466

Blanchard v Bl anchard (1994), 154 NBR (2d) 321, 5 CCPB 239, [1994]

NBJ No 489 (QB) .........................................................................................259